“The Lady or the Tiger and Other Stories by Frank Stockton is a fine, entertaining collection of original fairy tales and folklore told in the uniquely Victorian prose reflective of the era.
The title story itself was an unprecedented success that both pleased and later haunted the author, whom would have rather been remembered for his other fairy morality tales. But for all his talents as a writer, it was “The Lady or the Tiger” that would be most reprinted in anthologies and would serve as a template to the modern ‘puzzle story.’ This is made all the more tragic since Mr. Stockton other works were no less impressive or memorable.
The rest of the stories in this collection follow a faithful, but true, pathway that while not strictly original served as memorable story or archetypes that never seems to grow old or outdated.
We have the reluctant hero (the fairy Ting-a-Ling in the eponymous short story), a villainous dwarf or other type of monster; the wish-giving wizard, the forlorn princess, and the ambitious, but somewhat foppish, prince.
Some stories delve into the classic formulistic themes of friendship (“The Griffin and the Minor Canon”), love (“The Three Sisters and the Kilmaree”), quest adventure (“The Magician’s Daughter and the High-Born Boy”), and redemption (“Old Pipes and the Dryad”). These are, of course, standard themes of morality that can be found in fairy stories new or old, but at least the author has a wicked imagination and grand sense of humor to freshen it up.
If there is anything critical to be said of these stories is that they are oftentimes very violent, which is made all the more shocking considering that these stories were all to be published for the children’s marketplace. But considering that Mr. Stockton was working in the traditions of bloody Grimm fairy tales or the highly depressing mortality tales of Hans Christian Anderson, one can’t be too harsh for his stylistic pendants for violence. At least most of the characters on the serving end of the sword are the villains in the stories. But if the readers are not too offended by an occasional show of gore, The Lady or the Tiger is a memorable little book perfect for the child in all of us.”
treal wrote this review Wednesday, July 9 2008.
(
reply |
permalink )