“I hadn't read this book since I was a child, and I very much enjoyed this second reading, especially since I understand so much more of what is being said, or not said. I love the story and the hope and the goodness. I love that all of the characters have flaws, but none fatal. I love how the true spirit of a garden is captured and communicated so elegantly.
As to the annotation, I have mixed feelings. Some of it was very helpful in explaining things that I wouldn't understand, such as societal mores and customs. Sometimes, though, I found the annotation a bit annoying. There almost seems to be an over-concern with Frances Hodgson Burnett's religious views. While I think they are important, and certainly shaped the book she wrote, sometimes I wondered if the notes stretched a bit too far, or made the obvious too obvious. Much of it, I could have gathered from reading an unannotated version of the book.
All in all, though, I loved it. I wish I had more guidance reading this book as a child, and I certainly wish my girls would take the time to read this.”
Tracy wrote this review Thursday, August 21 2008.
(
reply |
permalink )
