- Marietta, GA, USA
- member since March 2, 2009
Re all your separation requests for various titles based on publisher. We don't really care about publisher. Combinations are based on content.
I'm going to reject these requests. If you resubmit, please add detail about content differences that may affect our decisions on the requests.
That series has zero books. However, as my DL persona, I am very familiar with the work and, I think but can't really remember, that I set up that series to begin with.
The problem Shelfari has with collective works is that they don't include them as numbered items. We Librarians have been berating them about this - and other issues associated with collective works as processed by Shelfari - since the feature was first introduced.
Is there something you'd like for me to do?
BTW - Although I received a confirmation about the issue (re my previous note to you) Amazon has not yet notified me of any decision. Unusual for them. It is more common for me to have a decision within 24 hours.
Re your separation request:
Catechumen submitted a request to move the edition The Civil War: A Narrative to a different book 16 hours ago.
see edition | see on Amazon | see cover
Comment: This is not a 3 volume set - it's only 1 volume
3 members have this edition.
Requested Target Work:
Fredericksburg to Meridian (collective work) by Shelby Foote
I'm rejecting it because I believe that Amazon's entry is in error. I've reported that problem to them. They are usually very swift to respond. When they do, we'll know better how to handle this situation.
I'll let you know when I hear back from them.