1 of 1 members found this review helpful.
“I'm a hearty believer in slow food and frustrated with the products that corporate farming is putting in our stores. I found this book by Kingsolver and her family to be fascinating in sections, it really made me think about what I'm eating. While reading it, I was growing my own container garden for the first time in several years, and so I found her celebration of growing things to be very powerful as well.
That said, I think Kingsolver is a bit preachy. She doesn't want to be, but she's so far ahead of the curve in terms of the life changes she's made that she just can't help it. Most of us just don't have the land or the time to eat entirely locally as she and her family did for a year. While I think it would be great if we could go back to the land more, the more realistic solutions for most of us involve promoting organic farming, local farmers, and getting our markets to do the right thing, which is a very tough row to hoe indeed. Changes in American energy policy and a movement to less energy-intensive transportation are also an important prerequisite to major adjustments in our food economy.
Also, it seems like some of the challenges of growing your own food are glossed over. There's very little about the plants that fail, the animals that die, or the bugs that swarm over everything when you try to grow organic. Kingsolver doesn't completely ignore these issues, but she find more success as a farmer than I've ever managed!
So in the end, I take some of this book with a grain of salt, but it's still good inspiration with lots of strong arguments. I don't recommend the audio version. Kingsolver's voice unfortunately has a tone that makes her positions seem even more preachy.”
Neil Hollands wrote this review Wednesday, September 10 2008.
(
reply |
permalink )