“This is a good book, but of course sad and depressing. Without spoiling the storyline, I'm glad that Clay's reason for being on the tapes was what it was, although I just did not like Hannah throughout the whole book. I kept wanting her to get help, or realize that she was great without everyone's approval, or SOMETHING! I mean, she was so freakin' creative in coming up with the tape idea, including masterminding their distribution, that she could have gone on to do amazingly wonderful things in life (but of course, then there would be no book... unless there's a sequel with some crazy twist). I would like to also hear from the points of view of the others on the tapes... like, another book, but from their perspective. I know this book is popular, and I did like reading it (realistic fiction is my fav) but I feel like there are so many things in the plot and writing style that I want to change! I think my favorite part was what happened after Jenny ran into the stop sign - not because I liked the awfulness of it, but because it's such a unique plot element for the author to come up with that outcome and how it was connected to everything else in the book. Overall, it's a good book, but I think I will like this author's next book better (once his writing improves) because he seems to have so much potential for intriguing stories!”
MsWrobel wrote this review Tuesday, October 27 2009.
(
reply |
permalink )