“ Wow, I absolutely loved this book! It was a bit weird reading a "Christmas" (well, holiday) story in March (when I'm really wishing it would just stay warm and stop snowing) but the 3-author gimmick, coupled with each author's unique style, is awesome. When I picked up this book, I was so excited to see who wrote it (John Green, Maureen Johnson, and Lauren Myracle) that I somehow missed the phrase "interconnected tales" on the back cover's description. So I didn't quite realize until I started reading the second story that all 3 had the same characters! I thought they were 3 separate stories. (Oops.) And technically, I think they would qualify as "novellas." Anyway, Johnson did a great job setting up the story with sarcasm and an "oh my god, I can't believe it could get worse" string of events, Green continued it with his signature style (where a ridiculous adventure is so well-written that you really believe it could happen), and Myracle had the toughest job of wrapping it all up -- in a Starbucks, no less! As a former barista (6 1/2 loooong years), I can verify that nearly every snarky comment she made about life a la Starbucks-style was true. (My only complaint was that there was one small reference to "mocha latte" ... *Technically* no one "in the know" calls it that - it's just a "mocha." But I can forgive her, as that's just my barista bitterness coming on strong!)
I highly recommend this book for young adult readers - the plot might be too confusing for younger readers, and a few bits of content might be too advanced for middle schoolers. Overall, each author did a wonderful job at including current references (iPods, Seven jeans, using the adjective "foxy," etc.) in a realistic way (as opposed to gratuitously trying to sound hip). And, I'm really glad that Addie did some intense thinking about her outlook on life!”
MsWrobel wrote this review Friday, March 6 2009.
(
reply |
permalink )