“Oh My Wow!
"Midnight and the Meaning of Love" finds Midnight on a quest to find his young wife who has been kidnapped by her father and taken back to Japan. As when he first arrived in America from Sudan, he again finds himself a foreigner in a strange, new land where he must quickly adjust and adapt. Midnight must overcome language barriers, traditions and a host of other things in his journey to reunite with his wife, Akemi.
Sequels often try too hard and in doing so forget to include a story. That would not be the case with "Midnight and the Meaning of Love." To the contrary, this book has too much story. Like its predecessor, it's a beast of a book at over 600 pages. Also like its predecessor, "Midnight: A Gangster Love Story," it's powerful, thought-provoking, too detailed and overly informative. Sister Souljah does a wonderful job of bringing other parts of the world and their culture to life as well as Midnight's struggles with maintaining his beliefs and otherwise. But in doing so, readers are also bogged down with a lot of details. Readers literally spend every second, minute and hour of the day with Midnight, his adventures and thoughts. At one point I felt like I was watching a Discovery Channel special on Japan and less about Midnight and the story at hand. Yes, some information was necessary to the story, but some of it could have been done away with.
I was disappointed and dismayed that after 608 pages, I'm still no closer to Midnight, the man from TCWE. We're still dealing with a 14-year-old kid (maybe 15 at this point). The only glimpse of familiarity for readers is the introduction of Midnight and Ricky Santiaga. But that moment was fleeting. Controversial and not always plausible, it's easy to either hate or love "Midnight and the Meaning of Love." While not exactly what I was hoping for, I can't hate on this book. To give it one star, as some have, is absurd. It's obvious that a lot of time, thought and research went into writing it, and I could never take that away from the author. She can write circles around many of the books in this genre today. Circles, squares and triangles! "Midnight and the Meaning of Love" possess depth, detail and it's very well written, so much so it's to its own detriment.
I seesawed with whether or not I could buy some of what Sister Souljah was selling. For example, the love in this book is strong. It's so strong that I question the deep level of love and the ability to express it in words and thoughts with the ages of these characters. But, I also know at that age that love can be all encompassing and extreme to a young mind finding love for the first time. Another example, Midnight's run-in and triumph with the U.S. military. I couldn't help but chuckle at the outlandishness of it all. So some things I could give the book a pass on, others had me looking sideways.
Now, with all that said, the good and the bad, it's time to stop playing! It took over 1000 pages between two books to get to where we are now - still in the mind of an adolescent boy. At this rate, how many more hundreds or thousands of pages will it take to connect and complete this series??? C'mon now! I'm trying to give Sister Souljah the benefit of the doubt and I appreciate the ambitiousness of this project and all that went into it, but let's get to what folks are waiting for. I'm sure she's tired of the comparisons of this to TCWE, as am I, BUT...TCWE is why we're all reading these Midnight books. We want to get to the Midnight we fell in love with or were intrigued by. It's time to stop playing and show us the connection and answer all questions. It's obvious there will be another book following this one and I plan to read it. But if that book doesn't close some gaps and answer some questions, I can't see myself continuing on after that. ”
Ms Toni wrote this review Wednesday, June 1, 2011.
(
reply |
permalink )