“It seems like with most short story collections I read, I always end up liking only a couple out of the entire lot. It's no different with The Dubliners. This is the second work of James Joyce I've read, after Portrait of An Artist as a Young Man, and because I'm unfamiliar with the vernacular and nuances of early 20th century life in Dublin, it is difficult to follow at times. (in fact, in reviewing some of the stories online afterwards, I completely missed a key plot line in "The Two Gallants"). In fact, I recommend skipping "Ivy Day in the Committee Room" entirely, as it deals with people complaining about Irish politics entirely.
Joyce unflinchingly depicts the social conventions of the working class, warts and all. Melancholy is the overwhelming feeling that envelops these stories.
A lot of the protagonists in theses stories are unsympathetic. The few that are sympathetic are frustrating as they have an ah-ha moment, and yet fail to do anything, or they just outright fail. In internet parlance: EPIC FAIL.
The story that resonates the most is the last and longest one, "The Dead". Gabriel, attends a party, and experiences various crises of confidence throughout the night. He rallies, but his emboldened state doesn't seem to last very long as he is shot down repeatedly. He delivers a rousing speech at dinner, the message of which he ironically comes to contradict in a realization at the end of the night.
This book took me a long time to finish, as I plodded through stories that I didn't particularly care for. In retrospect, I should have just skipped those and gone on to the next one.
”
K wrote this review Saturday, February 20, 2010.
(
reply |
permalink )