“I am between 3 1/2 and 4 stars, but just because I loved the series as a whole, I gave it 4 stars. I agreed with Meyer giving Bella exactly what she wanted and that was to become a vampire and be with Edward for eternity, but I felt as if everything Meyer fit into this book was too much for one book. I felt as if she had the need to wrap up every detail in Bella, Jake and Edward's life, so things like Jake imprinting on their daughter just to have Jake continue to be a part of Bella's life seemed a little silly, and also that Charlie accepted Bella and didn't question her about her life. Though this wasn't the best book in the series, I thought that the series as a whole was very creative and well written and I enjoyed every bit of it!”
lilbear77 wrote this review Saturday, August 23 2008.
(
reply |
permalink )