“The Likeness is Tana French’s sequel to In the Woods, a book I read several years ago and really enjoyed. I’m sorry to say that this book did not measure up. There are some spoilers ahead, so if you plan to read the first book then proceed at your own risk.
The story begins several months after the events at the end of In the Woods. Cassie Maddox is working Domestic Crimes after her last case “blew up”. She has a boyfriend and has settled into a new life, even if she still has feelings for Rob, her former partner. When a young woman is found murdered she bears an uncanny resemblance to Cassie and she is persuade to go undercover, posing as the murdered woman.
That’s the bare bones of the plot, but there were enough holes in this plot to drive a truck through. To believe that a woman could pose as another woman and live with her four roommates and nobody suspects a thing is mind-boggling. It gets even more confusing when it turns out the murdered woman is actually using a persona that Cassie had used years ago in another undercover case. When Cassie finds a vital piece of evidence on her first day she withholds that information from her boss. That police officer trying to get back in good graces with her superiors would withhold key information for no fathomable reason was unbelievable. And don’t get me started on Frank Mackey, Cassie’s boss. He is supposed to be an old style police officer, but the fact that he called Cassie babe at every turn drove me crazy. Since when does a superior officer speak like that? It was extremely annoying. The four roommates that Cassie/Lexi lived with were strange to put it mildly. What century did they come from? Their lifestyle was like a country manor from 1900 England, Downton Abby except with cell phones. Throwing in a plotline about a dead girl from 100 years ago that all the villagers were still up in arms about only served to confuse the situation.
French can write beautifully, however there is no need to write three paragraphs when a few sentences would do. I would find my eyes glazing over at times, wishing the author would please, please get to the point. To say that about 100 pages could have been cut from this book is no exaggeration. The foreshadowing also got tiresome. The most puzzling thing of all was why Cassie seemed to want to become Lexi; the author threw in a lot of psycho babble that did nothing to move the plot forward.
The ending was anti-climatic and after all the foreshadowing pretty much a foregone conclusion. About the only person in this book I liked was Cassie’s boyfriend Sam, he was the only one who didn’t seem like a caricature, except now that I think about it he was a little too good to be true.
A disappointment after In the Woods, scores the stars more for the bits of the book that were beautifully written, if you could find them beneath all the dross.
”