Books
Group avatar

Educator Summer (& all year) Reading

This group was created for educators interested in collaborating with the book list found here: http://is.gd/JYWM All books have been added as a discussion topic as well as the person(s) who suggested the title. If you don't see the book you want to talk about, click search discussions or feel free to add one.

« more discussions

  • John S

    Teach Like Your Hair's on Fire by Rafe Esquith

    Recommended by Adam DeWitt

    Recommended by Crista Anderson

    Recommended by Michelle Reagan "A very inspiring book for classroom teachers. I read this book last summer and couldn't wait to get back to school to incorporate some of his ideas into my classroom."

    John S started this discussion 5 months ago. ( reply )

26

replies
expand replies 
Sign in to participate in this discussion.
  • stacy k

    stacy k 

    I read this book last summer and was quite inspired by it. I have a feeling Rafe would join this group if someone would invite him.

    posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
  • Lee Kolbert

    Lee Kolbert 

    Let's invite him! Do you know how to get in touch with him?

    posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • mrlosik

      mrlosik 

      I sent Rafe an email inviting him to join our group here on Shelfari. I sent him an email right after I had read the book thanking him for the inspiration. He responded immediately. It would be great to have him join our conversation.

      posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
  • Lee Kolbert

    Lee Kolbert 

    This is going to be my first book. Is anyone else currently reading it?

    posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
    show 2 replies
    • Chad L

      Chad L 

      I'm going to start reading this as soon as I pick it up from the library. Which should be today or tomorrow.

      posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
    • Paula N

      Paula N 

      Lee,
      I just finished reading this book today. Boy does Rafe give me some food for thought. I admire the fact that he gives so freely of himself. I can't imagine too many teachers starting at 6:30 a.m. and ending at 6:00 p.m. everyday, or working on Saturdays and holidays. In order to get his students to achieve at such high levels the investment of time is needed. He shows that more time on task can be the great equalizer. which is also the philosophy of the KIPP schools as I read about in Malcolm Gladwell's Outlier (chapter 8). I am dedicated to my career, but am not in the same league as Rafe Esquith. His students are very fortunate indeed.

      I play Buzz with my math students but I will be ordering Macry Cook's math tiles he talks about. My favorite chapter is Six - We Won't Be Fooled Again. I will definitely be teaching my students how to "create the conditions of the test". I am anxious to use many of his ideas next year with my students.

      What are your thoughts?

      posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
  • mrlosik

    mrlosik 

    I read it this winter, but I am excited to go back and discuss it. I think there are some essential points that need to come to the forefront of education.

    posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
  • Sean W

    Sean W 

    Lee - I read it last summer but would enjoy revisiting. If you want to post thoughts as you go it might be fun to exchange ideas/discuss :)

    posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
  • Gail P

    Gail P (edited)

    Off to Barnes and Noble today Teach Like Your Hair's On Fire. I also want to get Living, Loving, and Learning for a retiring teacher. She deserves a book with that title after 40 years! of teaching grade 2.

    posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
  • Betty J

    Betty J 

    My copy should arrive within a few days.

    posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
  • A A

    A A 

    So I had a decent comment and then somehow my computer deleted it. Nice. Bottom line - while I am not sure that all of the book is applicable to my room I have found the book to be very inspiring. I am only a few chapters in, but am enjoying it. Thanks for the recommendation!

    posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
  • Lee Kolbert

    Lee Kolbert 

    My book just arrived. I'm going to finish the trashy book I'm currently reading ("Club Dead" the inspiration for the HBO series "Blood Ties"). Then I'm going to start this one. Looking forward to it.

    posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
  • mrbalcom

    mrbalcom 

    Picked up the book from the library today. Can't wait to start reading it.

    posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
  • Susanvg

    Susanvg 

    Just ordered from Amazon, but I am currently reading Engaging Readers and Writers with Inquiry by Jeffrey Wilhelm - enjoying it.

    posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
  • Chad L

    Chad L 

    I started reading "Teach Like Your Hair's On Fire" and have enjoyed the book so far. There is one thing, however, that I want to comment on first.

    "For almost twelve hours a day, six days a week, forty-eight week a year..." As Seth Meyers and Amy Poehler would say, "Really? Really, Rafe? " I'm sorry, but that's crazy. Sure, it sounds great for the students, but don't kids need downtime? Don't they need time to 'be kids?' I'm not so sure this type of regime allows for that. Doesn't Rafe need a break? What about his family? I couldn't be away from my family that much. I also don't see any students and families I've worked with, much less teachers, willing to make that commitment. In a lot of cases, I hear teachers mention that they could use more time with their students, but I've never heard any anything remotely close to this. I'm not even sure a school district would allow this to happen in my neck of the woods. They'd have to pay for other building staff to work hours when they normally wouldn't and also spend more money on utilities. Maybe money is more readily available here Rafe teaches, but I doubt it based on the description of his classroom.

    posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
  • Gail P

    Gail P (edited)

    Thanks for the candid response Chad. I have a family that is long since grown but even without the huge family commitment of time, I would never be able to pull off that much dedication. I hope that once I start reading TLYHOF I will pull in all the authors positive energy and excitement. An infusion of that will certainly be welcome now that the US is entering the summer break period. I genuinely do love my job, but I get weary of the lack of so many things like time, materials, planning, resources, technology tools, and a strong community of practice (PLC.) So rather than take his message in and make it my own, I think I'll use some of his ideas and attitude to create the recipe that can work best for me and my students.

    Thanks again for your candor and for really getting the conversation going here.

    (Now to finish the last 75 pages of a junk novel so I can honestly join in the discussion.)

    posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
  • Andria D

    Andria D 

    I loved this book! I like Gail's comment about using some of his ideas and making them your own. I loved how thouroughly he trained students to go on field trips.

    posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
  • Gail P

    Gail P (edited)

    Chapter 1 "Gimme Some Truth"
    I would like to relish this book especially since it looks to be a quick read. First, I have observed that Rafe Esquith is a work in progress. I like the fact that he has learned from experience and like any true master, he wants to share his learning with others.
    The teachers he writes about are teachers I have had in school myself. Working on the other side of the desk has revealed some of the reasoning behind their fear instilling behavior. Rafe puts the teaching experiences out there for review and I can see myself in each of them. While I don't think I am afraid of losing control of the class, there is no doubt a certain amount of fear generated by the way I run things.
    It sounds as though Rafe often takes a deep breath and just chills. When problems arise, and they do, he backs up a bit, quiets things down and rallys the troops behind him. That is genius. The trust building goes a very long way.
    I wholeheartedly agree with his observations on being dependable. Being honest and fair go a long way in any relationship and in a classroom, when students see the rules followed by logical consequences, they are empowered. They have some control over situations as well as their own actions and can read the writing on the wall when they mess up. It is sometimes tough for teachers to step back away from a conflict to look at it without becoming personally embroiled in the problem itself or taking it as a personal affront to their authority. Being dependable also creates a sense of safety and trust. This feeling of safety is necessary for learning.
    Being a good role model requires maturity and good character. It's hard to bring those things to a classroom if they are not part of your identity.

    Chapter 2 "Searching For Level VI"
    This Chapter has really set the bar for the rest of the book. We are taken through the different levels with examples of what it looks and feels like for both teacher and student. I have felt comfortable operating in Levels 1, 2, and 3 with a few kids falling into level 4. Let me add an important detail though. I teach kindergarten children and I believe our expectations for them are a bit different. Just as we are the last of the school to get Smart boards, or time with the laptops, we are also learning the ropes in self management and understanding how the whole idea of a social system works. A certain amount of maturity is expected before a person can step outside of their own experience and honestly understand what another is feeling. So whereas our goals may be the same as older students, our expectations for individual success depend a lot on outside experiences and maturity. I can envision a class of kindergarten students practicing levels 5 and 6 but if I leave the room, some of the physically dominant (oftentimes ADHD kids) will act up. They haven't learned to modulate their voices and certainly not their bodies. Given the smallest opportunity, they will jump out of their seats - dancing, acting out fight scenes, and touching each other in a variety of interesting ways. Humility is not yet on their horizon as they are still in the me, me, me phase of their lives.

    Does anyone else have experiences with or observations of the levels Rafe talks about?

    posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
  • Lee Kolbert

    Lee Kolbert 

    I just finished chapters 1 & 2. In theory, I agree with everything Rafe says, however we still live in the real world. For example, for years (when I was in the classroom), I struggled to not post a list of rules. I wanted to have a single rule; "Be Respectful and Earn Respect." That was it. I felt that covered everything; earning trust, talking out of turn, hitting, etc. Unfortunately, there were admins who felt there had to be a list with a set number of rules. This meant if the rule wasn't on the list it couldn't endorced. Besides, who has a list of rules in their house? This is just an example, but it's tough to stick your neck out there.

    posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
  • Gail P

    Gail P (edited)

    Part Two: The Method
    Chapter 3 Reading For Life

    I had to laugh when I read the first few pages here when Rafe talks about the staff meeting. Ours are not so laborious and seem to stick to bullet points of information with some timely discussions in table groups thrown in. I guess my administrator has seen the light.

    This chapter is dedicated to changing the face of reading as we know it. Rather than forcing students to read for tests, measurements, questionable comprehension and actually very little as far as connection to their own lives, Rafe wants us to put the love for reading in the front so that students will be life long readers. He is right when he says that we read for our own enjoyment. I am reading this text to learn more about how I can do my job better. That is personal motivation.

    I would be interested in hearing the thoughts of others who actually teach reading - to older kids. My kindergarten kids are not yet masters of reading and I am teaching them mostly basic concepts about navigating through a book.

    Chapter 4 Writing

    Hmmm. Now I'm committed here. I have started to recap my impressions of the chapters and how they may impact my teaching but Rafe has made me feel like a student again. I am presenting my best effort (in the little bit of time I can spare and with minimal rewrites) but I am writing about someone who teaches and grades real writing assignments and suddenly I'm feeling a bit shy about him possibly seeing my work.
    Okay, so I blow by that and move on.

    Step 1 Start Me up: Grammar / Interesting that this is in the writing chapter as I usually think of it as a speaking task but writing uses grammar as well and being able to present your thoughts aloud or in text carries the same onus. You want to communicate your thoughts comprehensibly and written words can be read and reread for ages to come. I like that Rafe gives grammar an important place in his classroom. I have heard that student essays for teacher exams are loaded with errors in both grammar and spelling. The reviewers are appalled by what they read and can't imagine that these students plan to teach others.

    Step 2 Essay of the Week / Good, rather simple task that teaches time management as well as writing. Because the task is repeated every week, the students can learn about what works and what doesn't work for them and their lives.

    Step 3 Monthly Book Report / I can appreciate the fact that Rafe asks them to choose a simple text for this exercise. If they comprehend the story and all its elements, they will be better able to reflect on the deeper meanings of the text and even draw comparisons to their own lives.

    Bringing these ideas back to my own kindergarten classroom experience, I can relate to the teaching of writing as an exciting and rewarding task. The students can feel the growth and see their own improvement. As a teacher, I can teach the elements at the time the student is most ready to learn them, and I can watch how they make the lesson their own. For some students it's developing a cohesive story idea; for others it's teaching the use of capital letters or the importance of spacing and punctuation. The writing continuum is a long one indeed, and I know my students and the things they will need to address at each session of Writers Workshop. Giving the students the tools they need to become good writers is critical and this process will go on throughout their school years.
    For those interested, you can see a piece of our Writers Workshop in action. I created this little video to share with a friend who was editing a book on writing and presenting many workshops on the subject. I wanted him to see that the writing process begins early on and needs a solid foundation in listening and speaking. Since this video, I have thought it would be a good idea to show all of the different parts of the writing experience as it relates to kindergarten. I'll save that project for next year as I only have 3 days left in this one.

    http://tinyurl.com/n3xloj

    posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
  • A A

    A A 

    I agree with both Lee and Gail. In theory a lot of what he writes about would work. He is also a self-admitted work in progress. Part of being a work in progress is that at times you get a lot of great ideas...but not answers. The answers or solutions that I find in the book are relative to room 56, but they don't necessarily fit in room 220 (my room:)). I do find the book inspiring...

    posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
  • Dlibrarian

    Dlibrarian 

    I've just picked up a copy at my district's professional library and am having a hard time putting it down. The opening statements about trust ring so true, and I'm afraid I recognize the teacher who yelled at "Adam" for having the messy book bag - it was me in the early years of my teaching. Yikes.

    posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
  • Gail P

    Gail P (edited)

    On to Chapters 5, 6, 7,.......

    Chapter 5: Add It Up
    This is a refreshing transition chapter. I like the way Rafe switches the brain processes by moving the kids around playfully using math work. It requires a different set of thinking skills to do math and the mental gymnastics helps the students to approach all learning in new ways.

    Chapter 6: We Won't Get Fooled Again
    The everyday work is where the learning is really going on and Rafe reminds us that the standardized tests get in the way of that. In kindergarten, we don't have the interruptions that older grades do. It sounds as though Rafe's district is beset by extra testing. Ugh. How can a teacher get on with her own formative assessing with so much interruption. It's the formative assessments that are so critical to informing instruction. That information dictates how a teacher will proceed on a very individual course for each student.

    Chapter 7: What a Wonderful World
    By the third paragraph, he had me pegged. I too feel the pressure to teach the core math and literacy work. Yes, I do integrate but as each "holiday" approaches, and worse passes by, I am reminded that I have missed another opportunity to teach the children things that have been fundamental in my own upbringing. Things like rights and responsibilities as granted by the Constitution as well as the states in the Union and more about our own government. Geography in general, is not going to get much attention in my room. Now in a more perfect world, I would have an interactive white board and could visit a new state or country every day with my class. We could create a big map of the world with flags for every place we were introduced to and we could create a basic list of facts that we would safeguard all year.
    I am struck once again by the lack of competition that goes on between students in Rafe's classroom. They recognize good work and applaud it. They do their own personal best and expect their peers are doing the same. Team work is fundamental and the idea that you can help others in your own way is too. Not only are the students learning facts about the countries of the world, they are developing new interests and learning more about cultures. They are true global citizens. American people tend to be too ethnocentric. Most Europeans can tell you about the US far better than we can in reverse.
    Rafe talks about viewing Soc. Stud. films after school. I have to wonder if most of his students are walkers or if there are "late buses" to bring the kids home. Picking up students after school would make the activity available to only a few at my school as parents aren't available to pick them up.

    Chapter 8: Rocket Man
    "Please Touch!" I like the sound of that. When it comes to teaching science it pays to provide the resources for manual exploration, especially since science is alive and all around us each and every day. Kindergarten science is one of my most favorite subjects to teach. (FYI here's a link to a hands on plant lesson in my K class this year http://poulingail.edublogs.org/archives/348 )
    Rafe took on the rocket building project. I imagine any teacher could give that one a try in its simplest form. "Okay class. Today we are going to build rockets. What do we know about rockets and what materials do you and your buddies think you will need? Let's get going and see what we can do!"

    Chapter 9: Art Lover
    For someone who says he is not an artist himself, Rafe takes on some serious art appreciation. He has presented a number of challenging projects that work at his grade level and he uses them to build a sense of community, organization, patience, planning, teamwork, and a pride in accomplishment. I like the idea that he has something meaningful starting on the first day. When the students get their hands on something - literally- they can relegate the stress they may feel into the piece while opening their minds and hearts to the learning. In our school we use the first 6 weeks as a time to build routines and establish that sense of community. The heavy content will be waiting for us down the road but initially we try to get a classroom that works well in groups and as individuals. That needs teaching and practice.

    Chapter 10: Put Me In Coach
    You mean to tell me you have to teach PE as well?! Do you even get a prep time? That explains the 12 hours a day and 6 days a week thing. Frankly, I'm stunned by this one. I have an exercise plan that we use daily in my class. We work each of the muscle groups and try to get the kids alert and also relaxed (tired out) with the activities. That is my nod to fitness, that and the fact that I encourage very active play and give the kids a very active indoor recess in the wide open cafeteria on rainy afternoons. But teaching actual PE?! Nope, not gonna happen. That being said, one of my students who has motor challenges said that one important thing he learned in kindergarten this year was how to do jumping jacks and crunches - he really did!

    posted 4 months ago. ( reply )
  • Betty J

    Betty J 

    I read this book today. I found it to be inspirational and am recommending to our instructional coach that we start a professional book club with it. Rafe has dedicated his life to the task of molding his students into productive and caring citizens. I agree with his motives and procedures. He plugs onward, no matter what, even when his classroom is destroyed by break-ins. As a former 5th grade teacher state, I can identify with him having to teach PE skills. However, I am dumb-founded that he seems to have no planning period, as Gail P. states in her discussion post. I also think that it is unrealistic to spend this much time with one's profession. The fact that he works on weekends and late at night makes me wonder how he keeps balance in his life. His wife must be the most understanding and supportive spouse in the universe. We all work after hours and weekends. However, I do not think that he is proposing that we should all do what he does; but rather, reflect on our own practices and take away some ideas or "sparks" that we can ignite in our own schools. What I get from the reading is that organization, planning, commitment, and resources will improve our lives and that we can all overcome obstacles if we keep these in mind, whether we are teachers or students. By the way, I am a media specialist now but have still come away with some ideas related to Rafe's book.

    posted 4 months ago. ( reply )
  • Lee Kolbert

    Lee Kolbert 

    I'm reading this a little slower than all of you, but I'll jump in anyway. I was laughing about his description of faculty meetings as they seem to be same everywhere. I wonder what can be done to change the format. Do administrators feel we have to be there face to face in one room in order to get tons of information? Do they think if they just ask us to read something, look at some results of something or consider something for discussion, that we simply won't do it? There's got to be a better way.

    posted 4 months ago. ( reply )
  • Gail P

    Gail P 

    After several weeks reading other titles, I have come back to finally finish TLYHOF. I won't dissect the chapters, only talk about the use of music and theater in Rafe's classroom. Being an artist at heart as well as a gifted teacher, Rafe thinks, lives, and breathes the arts. He moves fluidly between the music of his life, especially rock music, the use of instruments as a learning experience and challenge, and truly relishing Shakespeare through total immersion. His students love to be challenged in the arts and use it as a springboard to developing strong character and responsibility. That seems to be the echoing element of all the chapters. The students learn to take on responsibility for their time and learning. They trust Rafe will be there to help them meets the challenges and appreciate his confidence in them.
    I continue to reflect on how I can incorporate Rafe's ideas in my kindergarten classroom. Seeing the skills and experiences as being on a continuum means I can find my own areas for student responsibility. The challenges will come but as a teacher, I need to have confidence that the students will do their best and see their own progress measured against a personal yardstick as well as the general expectations for the whole class.

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • To reply to this discussion, please sign in or join now.

Return to top