Books
Group avatar

Anything Goes

This is an "anything goes" forum--a fun place to discuss your books and favorite shows no matter the genre. Feel free to jump in on a post or start your own discussion. Got an idea for a word game? Post it! Feel free to chat! We'd love to hear from you!

« more discussions

  • Evie ♥

    Team Peeta or Team Gale?

    **Will probably contain spoilers!**

    The romance thread in The Hunger Games and Catching Fire isn't the main story line, but readers still become emotionally vested in Catniss Everdeen's relationship with Peeta and Gale.

    Are you Team Peeta or Team Gale? What are your thoughts on book three?
    Evie ♥ started this discussion 2 months ago. ( reply )

33

replies
expand replies 
Sign in to participate in this discussion.
  • Evie ♥

    Evie ♥ 

    I'm Team Peeta and believe his feelings for Catniss are sincere. IMHO, I think Catniss' feelings for Peeta go beyond her wanting him to be the voice of the revolution. Catniss and Gale have history but Peeta and Cat do too. (Plus Peeta is in the book much more than Gale so I don't feel I know him as well. I guess that doesn't really matter because Catniss knows him well enough!!) :D I do like Gale--I'd just like to see Cat and Peeta end up together. Since the romance is sub-plot and considering all that will be happening in book 3, I don't expect that Cat will choose between either of them in the traditional sense. Probably circumstances will choose for her if she survives. I think she may sacrifice herself for the greater good, as Peeta and Gale may do. Who knows? I think it's going to be heart wrenching, no matter what happens.

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • Dazzling Mage

    Dazzling Mage 

    I'm also Team Peeta. It may be predictable, but I love the relationship between the two. And I think Haymitch voices it out to everyone that Katniss does not deserve him, and that he's too good for her, but the relationship/experience they went through in the games is sort of exclusive to them. While it's frustrating that the romance is BARELY there, I love how it's not forced on Katniss either. Let the feelings grow, form and mean something, and that's what Katniss is doing.

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • Tricia S

    Tricia S 

    I'm torn :( I really have loved Peeta from the beginning but I like Gale too! I have a feeling we will get more of a chance to get to know Gale in the next book, he really hasn't done anything for me not to like him he has more in common with Catniss but that could also lead to a big brother kinda love.

    posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    show 2 replies
    • Evie ♥

      Evie ♥ 

      At the beginning of THG, I was very interested in Gale. The way he's described, he sounds so perfect, so at the end I was surprised at how I fell for Peeta, and how little Gale was in the story. In Catching Fire, I was expecting more of Gale, but it still played out nicely. My boyfriend thinks Gale will out in the end, though. That the years they shared amount to more than the crisis Peeta and Cat went through.

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    • Tricia S

      Tricia S 

      I really felt sorry for her in Catching Fire you could tell it was tearing her up to think of having to choose one or the other. I loved Peeta even more though for the way he steps back and tries to be a friend to her and not push.

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
  • Liv S

    Liv S 

    I'm for Peeta all the way! They need one another. On multiple occasions, both Kat & Peeta have been willing to give up their own lives for the other. I haven't seen Gale offer up that kind of sacrafice. Even though Katniss "faked" some of her affection even she admits that she's reluctant to let go of Peeta's hand at the end of THG. Yes, Gale is a great catch, but he and Katniss are too much alike. Gale and Katniss are too jaded to have developed that kind of relationship before, and now it's a little too late. Plus, I think there's something going on with Gale and Madge. I know there are some holes in my theory (like Madge having to survive the bombing of dist 12), but it works out nicely in my head.

    posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    show 4 replies
    • candace_redinger

      candace_redinger 

      Gale and Madge... hmmm... that's not a bad idea.

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    • Evie ♥

      Evie ♥ (edited)

      Plus, I think there's something going on with Gale and Madge. I know there are some holes in my theory (like Madge having to survive the bombing of dist 12), but it works out nicely in my head.

      "works out nicely in myr head" made me smile! :D I know just what you mean!

      Gale and Madge...didn't think of that but good one! Sometimes I think I read books too fast or am too distracted because I forget a lot of stuff until somebody mentions it on here..

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    • Liv S

      Liv S 

      The Gale and Madge thing popped out at me when Haymitch starts to wonder why Madge braves the storm to bring Gale some pain meds. Katsa actually gets all defensive at Haymitch's questioning.

      I also think that, once the Capital is overthrown, Haymitch and Gale's mom will pair off. Haymitch won't have to live a solitary life with the threat of his children having to compete in the Hunger Games. (Which, I think is why he's chosen not to marry.)

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    • Evie ♥

      Evie ♥ 

      I thought that, too, about Haymitch. The games are why he drinks so much.

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
  • candace_redinger

    candace_redinger 

    I think I'm team Peeta now. I didn't know before but after finishing Catching Fire I believe I am. Some of that may be because we know him better though. I just think his love for Katniss is so great and so, well, amazing. And I think she just doesn't realize how much she really does love him.
    I really cannot wait for the next book. It's going to drive me crazy. I think Gale may be in the next book more too since he was with them at the end and Peeta wasn't.

    posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • Liv S

      Liv S 

      I think there's going to be a lot of Gale in Book 3 also.

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
  • Evie ♥

    Evie ♥ (edited)

    Didn't you all just love what Cinna did with Catniss' wedding dress? I was really surprised and it was written so well I could imagine it perfectly. I hope Cinna isn't dead. He is a very strong, influential minor character (even more so than Gale?)

    posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    show 4 replies
    • candace_redinger

      candace_redinger 

      I loved what he did with her dress!

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    • Liv S

      Liv S 

      Yes, I was happy with his edits to Kat's dress.

      I've been talking about Cinna in The Hunger Games group that I belong to. There are lots of us who really, really, really, hope that Cinna isn't dead. Someone theorized that he'll be turned into an Avox rather than be killed because the Capital might be able to use him as a pawn to get to Katniss. I don't like that he'll be tongue-less, but I'm hoping that he'll be around in book 3.

      I'm wondering about your question of whether Cinna is more influential than Gale. I'm thinking that I'd follow that reasoning. I'll have to debate it out in my head for a bit and get back to you.

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    • Evie ♥

      Evie ♥ 

      Cinna an Avox. Ouch, I can see the Capital doing that.

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    • Tricia S

      Tricia S 

      I really liked Cinna :(

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
  • Evie ♥

    Evie ♥ 

    What do you think the Capital will do to PEETA?!! They'll keep him alive as a way of getting to Kat, Gale, Haymitch, et all, but I hope they don't turn him into an Avox.

    posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    show 6 replies
    • Liv S

      Liv S 

      OMG!!! It never occured to me that the Capital would turn Peeta into an Avox. Damn it!! They might do that, since he is so good with words. Ugh... this is gut wrenching! I want Book 3!

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    • Evie ♥

      Evie ♥ 

      Do you think they would though? The crowd loves Peeta. Wouldn't it fuel the rebellion or whatever if they did anything to Peeta? I'm just trying to calm myself down--I'd hate it if anything happened to Peeta.

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    • Tricia S

      Tricia S 

      I don't think the Capital will do that to Peeta. They are still trying to make it look as though everything is the same and that there isn't a rebellion happening in the other districts, to the people who live within the capital?

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    • Liv S

      Liv S 

      They were trying to downplay the rebellion, but I don't see how they can keep it a secret now that the Games have been interrupted.

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    • Tricia S

      Tricia S 

      hmm maybe not but darn I don't want to see him made into Avox.

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    • Liv S

      Liv S 

      Me neither, Tricia. Me neither!

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
  • dukesangel002

    dukesangel002 

    I team have 2 boyfriends ;-) Lmbo. Can't help it, I always seem to want them both!

    posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    show 4 replies
    • Evie ♥

      Evie ♥ 

      I was Team Edward AND Jacob but I'm clearly in Peeta's camp this time. I'm so afraid of what's going to happen to him ;;

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    • dukesangel002

      dukesangel002 

      LOL, I"m Edward and Jacob, Peeta and Gale, Michael and Shane (I know that Michael was never an interest for Claire but I want him to be...lol), Stark and Heath, and there are many more where I want double guys...lol.

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    • Evie ♥

      Evie ♥ (edited)

      OMG, Micheal and Shane...I'm not caught up on that series! Shane and Claire need to do the wild monkey dance. SO frustrating!

      Who are Stark and Heath?

      posted 3 weeks ago. ( reply )
    • candace_redinger

      candace_redinger 

      Stark and Heath are from the House of Night series by the Casts.

      posted 3 weeks ago. ( reply )
  • Evie ♥

    Evie ♥ 

    In Support of Team Peeta

    I started re-reading The Hunger Games and I'm noticing things I didn't the first time through.

    Katniss actually says she's never thought of Gale in a romantic way.

    Gale and Madge have a "testing the waters" moment on Madge's doorstep, when Gale says her dress is pretty and she responds that she needs to look her best for when the tributes are chosen. Katniss observes this and feels jealous, but only because "good hunting partners are hard to find." Initially, I thought this was just silly denial of a budding romance, but now I think they are more like best friends/siblings.

    Katniss and Peeta defend the other's abilities in front of Haymitch. Katniss remembers that Peeta came in second in wrestling (only losing to his brother). She says something along the lines of "Apparently I've been keeping up with the baker's son, after all."

    I loved Cinna the first time through, but I appreciate him so much more now. It seems as if so many things are lining up for Katniss and Peeta to be revolutionaries: their spirit that pierces Haymitch's drunken fog that first day on the train, Cinna, in his first year as a stylist actually choosing to be assigned to District 12, and at the last moment deciding for Katniss and Peeta to hold hands on their chariot ride--a rebellious move to present them as partners.

    posted 2 weeks ago. ( reply )
    show 3 replies
    • Liv S

      Liv S 

      Nice! The Gale/Madge thing is as good as sold!

      posted 2 weeks ago. ( reply )
    • Evie ♥

      Evie ♥ 

      I'm reading Catching Fire again, so I'll be able to add more, but Liv, good call on Madge and Gale. I wouldn't have seen it if it weren't for you!

      posted 2 weeks ago. ( reply )
    • Liv S

      Liv S 

      Thanks, Evie! Anytime! I'm thinking about picking these books up again. Then we'll pow wow some more.

      posted 2 weeks ago. ( reply )
  • To reply to this discussion, please sign in or join now.

Return to top