Books
Group avatar

Play Book Tag


Come play with us!!

The tag for March is:
Science

To learn more, please read our "FAQ for New Play Book Tag Members."

Our store is located at:
http://astore.amazon.com/httpfightinbl-20
Just click on the "powered by Amazon" logo in the upper left hand corner to shop the ENTIRE...more »

« more discussions

  • againstthetide

    On the Sixth Day of Christmas, My True Love Gave to Me . . .

    Six Geese A-Laying.

    Our sixth tag is:

    Family


    Just a reminder, you want to try to link this sixth read back to the fifth in one or more of the following ways (if you can). Each link is worth one point.

    a) Same author
    b) Shares at least one word in the title (articles don't count)
    c) Published in the same year
    d) Won or was nominated for the same prize
    e) Is in the same genre (as judged by the admins)
    f) Is set in the same country
    g) Come up with ONE additional bond using your own creativity

    If you need more directions for this Challenge, you can find them here:
    http://www.shelfari.com/groups/21541/discussions/153791/Twelve-Days-of-Christmas-Challenge---Starting-November-9th-

    Please post your reviews and scores in this thread. A brief guide to scoring for this week:

    a) Reading a book that fits the tag, "Family" = 2 points
    b) If the book also fits the tag "satire" = 3 more points
    c) Review the book = 5 points
    d) 1 point for each link
    againstthetide started this discussion 3 months ago. ( reply )

46

replies
expand replies 
Sign in to participate in this discussion.
  • Regina L

    Regina L 

    If you read a book during the opening of the game but before this post, does it count?

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • ghost of a rose

    ghost of a rose 

    I was wondering about that too!

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • LibraryCin

    LibraryCin 

    I was assuming that you had to read something for the tag after it was posted, but that was just my assumption.

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • againstthetide

      againstthetide 

      Cindy is correct. The book must be read after the tag is posted. You can't just get "lucky" . . .lol . . .and pull one out from your stash of prior reads. As tempting as that must be ;).

      posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • Colleen S

    Colleen S 

    The Land of Mango Sunsets by Dorothea Benton Frank </b>
    4 stars

    Miriam Elizabeth Swanson is in a snit. Her husband left her for a lingerie model who's barely an adult and her grown sons are busy with their own lives, her tenant Liz is sleeping with the husband of a society acquaintance of hers, and her best friends are Kevin, the head of visual displays at a department store and her pet parrot Harry. Miriam decides to make some changes in her life so she heads south to Sullivan's Island to spend some time with her mother. There, she meets a man named Harrison Ford (no, not that Harrison Ford) who makes her laugh and calls her Mellie.

    I started out not liking this book too much, which surprised me because I usually love Frank's books, but once Miriam stops feeling sorry for herself and makes some changes to her life, I wound up not being able to put it down.

    Scoring:
    tag--"family"--2 points
    review--5 points
    set in same country as The Actor and the Housewife (usa)--1 point
    female authors (Shannon Hale and Dorothea Benton Frank--1 point
    both books had the loss of a loved one due to cancer--1 point
    previous points--42
    New Total: 52 points

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
    show 2 replies
    • Kentucky Reader

      Kentucky Reader 

      I read a couple of hers. Loved one and hated one, but this sounds like one I would like.

      posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
    • Nicole R

      Nicole R 

      Colleen~ The "female authors" and "loss of a loved one" are both creative tags and you can only claim one :( I am recording your score at 9 for this round and a total of 51.

      posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • sharmee

    sharmee 

    Invisible Monsters by Chuck Palahnuik

    4 stars

    I have read Survivor by this author, and although it was definitely different, it was a great book. I listened to the audio book of Invisible Monsters, and I enjoyed it much more than I thought I would. He definitely has a different way of writing a novel. This story had so many twists and turns especially towards the end that I would stay in my car and finish listening and be late to work. OR I would run to my room as soon as I got home to put the CD in and listen. I have to admit though, that so far with Palahnuik's books, I get confused and I have to re-read(re-listen) to pieces because it is pretty confusing.
    Invisible Monsters was about a model who gets her face shot at to the point where she has no more jaw, she can't speak, and her face is so disfigured that she has to cover it everywhere she goes. I don't want to say too much without giving away all of the jaw-dropping twists. I will definitely read more of Chuck Palahnuik :)

    "family" tag: 3
    "satire" tag: 2
    review: 5
    Links to previous book -
    "monsters" in both titles: 1
    additional link: they are both "dark" comedies- 1
    Total for Day 6: 12
    Previous total: 62

    NEW TOTAL: 74

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • Rachel H

    Rachel H 

    Me talk Pretty One Day by David Sedaris 3 stars

    This is the second David Sedaris book I've read and the second half of this one seemed more organised. I foudn some of his stories amusing but the jumping around between ages and places in the first half of the book got on my nerves. I enjoyed the second half which mainly centered around Sedaris' efforts to learn French.

    family tag: 2 points
    satire tag: 3 points
    review: 5 points
    links to round 5; absolutely none :-)

    Total round 6: 10 points

    Overall total: 65 points

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • Kristel

    Kristel (edited)

    The Metamorphosis by Franz Kafka
    4 stars
    This is really a short story, but an excellent example of Kafka's style. Franz Kafka was born in Prague. He was a member of the well to do middle class Jewish merchant. Kafka worked in the insurance business. He was always impressed with his father's successes and always felt inferior. This story is about a son in a family of two parents and a sister. The son is working in sales and travels. He is the main provider for the family. He doesn't like his job but feels powerless to quit. One day he wakes up and he is a dung beetle. His family, at first are in horror, but then try to care for him and great cost to their well being. They finally as a family group wish to be rid of him. Kafka's style is one of great detail. This story read as a possible autobiography of Kafka of his relationship to his father and family.

    Cross posted to Satire

    Family tag=2 points
    Satire Tag=3 points
    Review=5 points
    Links to round 5, both authors born in Prague=1 point
    Total pts, round 6=11
    Previous points=50
    Total pts=61

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
    show 3 replies
    • Kentucky Reader

      Kentucky Reader 

      I've always loved this story. Congratulations on your creative link. Two different authors in a row born in Prague must be a rarity.

      posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
    • Kristel

      Kristel (edited)

      took a lot of searching to do so. And to find something that isn't going to take forever to read, well that is quite the tricky part.

      posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
    • Kentucky Reader

      Kentucky Reader 

      Finding something that's just the right fit certainly is tricky!

      posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • Play Book Tag Shelf

    Play Book Tag Shelf 

    12-19-09 Shelf is updated.

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • Erin S

    Erin S 

    The Handmaid's Tale by Margaret Atwood
    5 stars

    In the Republic of Gilead, Offred lives as a Handmaid in the home of the Commander and his wife. Her value comes only if she can become pregnant with the Commander's child. Offred describes life as a Handmaid and how she went from a wife and mother with a career to merely a vessel with no personal freedom.

    Wow! That's about all I can really think to say about this book. This was a terrifying, dystopian novel and very clever satire on a patriarichal society. I think any woman would be able to connect to the character of Offred and her debasement as a woman. Imagine not even being allowed to read! What most impressed me was the author's ability to reveal just enough detail about Offred's world, (but not too much detail) that your imagination begins to run wild. I probably filled in the blanks with more horrific details than anything explicitly mentioned in the book. Easily one of the best books I have read this year.

    "Family" tag- 2 points
    "Satire" tag - 3 points
    Review - 5 points
    Links to Jane Eyre - 1 point
    g. Both novels feature female main protagonists
    Round total - 11 points
    Previous Score - 50 points

    Total Points - 61 points

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • Deedge

    Deedge 

    Like Water for Chocolate by Laura Esquivel
    5 stars

    Tita is the youngest daughter and carries a personal curse. She is forbidden to marry because she has to care for her mother until her death. This is a problem when she is attracted to Pedro. However Pedro is marrying her sister and soon his intentions are revealed as he is just trying to get close to Tita.

    This book was one of my first relationship books (other than Effigy, which I hated) and I really liked it. This is very similar to some sci-fi and fantasy books I like to read. I think I have to admit that despite the 5 stars I still enjoy sci-fi as much. At times, that enchantment can make it more dramatic. However, I think I may consider more books similar to Like Water for Chocolate provided the emotions are crisp and clear, the drama is always in existence and the book doesn't follow Effigy's examples and put too much in and get out a pasty sludge.

    links:
    e) Shares a genre of family/marriage
    g) Both novels are written by female authors

    After round 5 score = 52 pts.

    tag: 'family' = 2 pts.
    review = 5 pts.
    links = 2 pts.

    After round 6 score = 61 pts.

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • Nicole R

      Nicole R (edited)

      Hi Deedge~ Unfortunately, family/marriage isn't a genre even though it is a topic they may have in common. Genres would include things like: historical fiction, autobiography, paranormal romance, etc. Do these two books share a genre like that?

      For now, I am recording your score as 8 points for this round and 60 pts overall.

      posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • Isabelle S

    Isabelle S 

    A Short History of Tractors in Ukranian by Marina Lewycka
    3 stars

    The first few sentences give you a summary of the story: "Two years after my mother died, my father fell in love with a glamorous blond Ukrainian divorcee. He was eighty-four and she was thirty-six. She exploded into our lives like a fluffy pink grenade, churning up the murky water, bringing to the surface sludge of sloughed-off memories, giving the family ghosts a kick up the backside."

    The narrator is Nadezhda, a late-40s professor at a polytechnic university. She has a husband and a daughter and shops at Oxfam. Her sister Vera, ten years older, has two daughters and the spoils of three rather lucrative divorces, and carries Gucci bags. The sisters rarely speak, particularly after a row over the division of their mother's bequest. But the appearance of Valentina, she of the "superior, Botticellian breasts" and rapacious greed, unites the sisters against a common enemy.

    This book is difficult for me to categorize. It's billed in several places as a comedy - "hilarity ensues." But while the saga of Nikolai and Valentina is written in many places as farcical, but for the most part to me the humor wasn't black, just grey and sad. Valentina's a grasping wench, but she's clawing her way out of "Ukraina' any way she can, wanting better for her pampered, self-important teenage son. Nikolai wants to pretend he's still young and vital and desirable, and if it's only for his money he's prepared to deal with that. But his daughters aren't, particularly when Valentina becomes abusive when the money isn't there.

    Lewycka is great at writing family dynamics. I especially related to the way Nadia, as the baby of the family, finds herself reverting to a "bogey-nosed four year old" in her interactions with her perennially big sister. And perhaps because my own father is Nikolai's age and recently widowed, I was moved at how well Lewycka portrays the quandary an aging parent presents for an adult child - that mix of childhood hero, his own personal history and the infirmities (physical and sometimes mental) of the aging. Just when Nikolai is at his most illogical and childlike, Lewycka lets him read another short excerpt from his history of tractors, and insightful look at the economic, political and social impact of this simple machine on an entire country. Or Nadia uncovers another memory from the family's escape from Stalin-era Ukraine, and the dangers and deprivations faced by ordinary people just trying to survive. And I liked how she let Nadia come right up to some family truths, but didn't unpack and belabor them, just set them aside as Nadia (finally) matures a bit and decides what really matters.

    The audio version is read by Sian Thomas, who does an incredible job with the Ukranian accents.

    Family tag: 2 points
    Review: 5 points
    Links to previous book: I'm an abject failure at this part of the game

    Previous score: 45 points
    Current score: 52

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • LibraryCin

      LibraryCin 

      Isabelle, I do a pretty good job of failing to link my books as well. You're doing much better at adding up points, though. Must be the month tag? I don't think a single one of the books I've read for the game has also matched up with the month tag!

      posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • Ellen R

    Ellen R 

    So B. It - Sarah Weeks
    3 stars

    Twelve years ago in Reno, Nevada, Bernadette heard a commotion outside her apartment door where she found a frightened young woman clutching a tiny infant in her arms. The young woman was obviously mentally disabled and only able to tell Bernadette "Heidi" and pointed to the child and "So B. It" and pointed at herself. Kindly Bernie takes in the mother and child and the three become an extended family. As Heidi grows up she learns to take care of her mother with Bernie's help. Bernie suffers from agoraphobia so Heidi is home-schooled and runs all the errands. Although she loves her life with her mother and Bernie Heidi has always longed to know where she came from and if she has other family. So B. It knows only 23 words and will never be able to tell Heidi about her past.

    While cleaning closets and drawers one day Heidi finds a camera with used film still loaded inside. Heidi has the pictures developed and is surprised to see her then-pregnant mother standing with a group of people having a Christmas party. Another photo shows the group standing on the front porch of a large house with a sign that reads "Hilltop Home - Liberty, New York". Most of the younger people in the photo appear to be physically and mentally disabled like So B. It. Heidi and Bernie try calling the Hilltop Home but their questions go unanswered so Heidi decides she will have to go there herself.
    Heidi buys a ticket on a cross country bus and sets off to solve the mystery of So B. It and Hilltop House.

    This YA story was very sweet and the ending was mostly satisfying but a real tear jerker. It was just very unrealistic to me for a twelve year old, no matter how mature, to have managed such an undertaking on her own. I guess that's why it's called 'fiction', right?

    Family Tag: 2 points
    Review: 5 points
    Tag 'F": both books set in the US 1 point
    Tag 'G": both books featured mothers with a catastrophic illness 1 point
    Day 6 Total: 9 points
    Previous Total: 46 points
    Total: 55 points

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
  • i.should.b.reading

    i.should.b.reading 

    The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins
    Rating: 5 stars

    I loved this book!! From the beginning the book captured me and had me waiting to see what would happen. The book takes place after some rebellion in what was the USA. Now, each year tributes must be sent from all districts to participate in the hunger games. The names in the drawing are children from 12 to 18. The drawing partly reminds me of the lottery and the hunger games themselves remind me of survivor except nobody is voted off. Katniss volunteers when her younger sister's name is drawn. She is willing to sacrifice herself for her sister. Then Peeta's name is drawn. He is the baker's son. Together they represent District 12. Their district has only had one winner so the chances for either doesn't look good. The book does show you what the Hunger Games are like, but I didn't think it was gruesome. It kept me on the edge of my seat worrying about Katniss and Peeta. I'm also glad that I already have Catching Fire waiting for me to read it.

    Previous Total: 47 points
    family tag: 2 points
    review: 5 points
    Links:
    set in same country 1 pt (I think this works since The Hunger Games tells at some point about going to the Rocky Mountains you know it's the US. The Custom of the Country takes place in New York)
    Other Link: Women Writers 1 pt
    Total: 56 points

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • Kentucky Reader

      Kentucky Reader 

      I sampled this on my Kindle and thought it looked good. It's on my TBR.

      posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • Kentucky Reader

    Kentucky Reader 

    Northanger Abbey, Jane Austen
    4 stars

    This is Jane Austen's first novel, although it was published last, after her death. In her forward, she is obviously a bit miffed that the publisher who bought the novel she wrote in 1803 never published it, so she bought it back in 1813. That's why her references throughout the book to other authors and their novels are outdated, she explains. Of course you don't have to be familiar with the low-brow Gothic novels popular at the time, and which she spoofs, to get the point of her satire or to enjoy this novel.

    The protagonist of Northanger Abbey is Catherine Moreland, age 17, among the youngest in the large brood of a clergyman and his wife in a small English village, and who devours Gothic novels. She is just growing out of her tom-boy stage and now fancies herself to soon be a heroine, as she believes real life is the same as life depicted in her soap opera type books.

    The Moreland's neighbors, the Allens, are a wealthy childless couple and are especially fond of Catherine. When they decide to take the doctor's advice and go to Bath, a popular hot springs resort of the time, for Mr. Allen's health, they invite Catherine to go with them. She's never been away from home before, so she does a lot of growing up through her experiences at Bath and later at Northanger Abbey.

    Soon after arriving at Bath, the naive and gullible Catherine meets Isabelle Thorpe, whose brother happens to be a classmate at Oxford of Catherine's older brother. The Thorpes are manipulative and incapable of telling a truth. Their mother is a widow with limited finances and they're determined to marry into money, setting their sights on Catherine and her brother. While pretending to be her friends, they make more than a little trouble for Catherine.

    Much of the satire of Gothic novels comes from the witty dialogue of Henry, another young man Catherine meets at Bath, as he teases her about her reading matter and her inability to separate fact from fiction. While at Bath, she's easily manipulated by the Thorpes with the promise of a tour of a real-life Gothic castle, just like the ones in her books. Later at Northanger Abbey, which is really no more than a former abbey renovated into a modern and very nice family home, she fancies herself to be a Gothic heroine about to solve a murder as she searches wardrobes, chests and secluded rooms.

    After nearly three months away, Catherine returns home wiser but heartbroken and dejected. "Live and learn," her mother says, just as mothers are still saying nearly a hundred years later. But Mrs. Moreland is proud of her newly-matured daughter, telling Mrs. Allen that Catherine has proven she can now "shift for herself."

    After much sadness, duplicity and several misunderstandings, all ends romantically and happily. There's even a Gothic style twist thrown in.

    Family tag = 2 points
    Satire tag = 3 more points
    Review = 5 points

    Additional links = 3 points
    e) Same genre -- Romance
    f) Same country -- England
    g) Additional bond -- both are tagged as 1001 books you must read before you die

    Previous total = 58 points
    Today's total = 13 points

    NEW TOTAL = 71 POINTS

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • LibraryCin

      LibraryCin 

      This sounds good, KR. I might have to add it to the list of Austen novels I'd like to get to...

      posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • Nicole R

    Nicole R 

    Scores recorded - 12/20/2009

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • Regina L

    Regina L 

    Grapes of Wrath by John Steinbeck
    3 stars

    Tom Joad returns, released from prison on parole, hitches a ride home. Tom discovers the home place abadoned and in disrepair. After visiting with one of the neighbors, who has stayed behind to "keep an eye on thing," Tom learns that the family has moved in with his uncle. It has become impossible for farmers to sustain a living under the conditions of the dust bowl. Tom sets out to reunite with his family and learns they have plans to head west to California with visions of land abundant in grapes and oranges dancing. Although on parole and prohibited from leaving the state, heads out with his family on Route 66 towards California.


    This is a much different book than other Steinbeck books that I have read, but is an important read in American Literature and historical fiction.


    Previous Point 46
    Family Tag: 2 pt
    Reveiw 5 pts
    Good Earth and Grapes of Wrath both won Pulitzer Prize 1pt
    Same Genre: Classic Lit 1 pt
    Creative Lit: Books won author Nobel Peace Prize

    Total = 56 pts

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • Shuva A

    Shuva A 

    The Namesake - Jhumpa Lahiri

    4 stars

    Family Tag - 2 pts
    Both books have Marriage as tag - 1 pt

    Previous pts - 23

    Total pts = 26

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • Play Book Tag Shelf

    Play Book Tag Shelf 

    12-23-09 Shelf is updated.

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • loves2teach03

    loves2teach03 

    After by Amy Efaw
    4 stars

    Devon is a 16 year old straight A student and star soccer player. She is also currently locked up in a juvenile detention center, charged with attempted murder for leaving her baby in a dumpster. Devon claims that she didn't know that she was pregnant. Her lawyer, Dom, is fighting to keep Devon in the juvenile court system, instead of being tried as an adult. Other issues surface along the way as Devon is forced to confront her past.

    This was an enjoyable young adult read...I was totally unsure of how the book was going to end.

    ~previous points: 42

    ~family tag: 2 pts.
    ~review: 5 pts.
    ~link - same country (USA): 1 pt.

    Total: 8 pts.

    ~current total: 50 pts.

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • againstthetide

    againstthetide 

    Scored through here 12/26

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • kairilily

    kairilily 

    Skipping Christmas by John Grisham
    3 stars

    With the Kranks only daughter, Blair, in Peru with the Peace Corps, they find themselves not feeling very festive this holiday season. Nora is always thinking about Blair and on the verge of tears, while Luther, an accountant, starts looking into how much money Christmas costs them every year. Luther gets the bright idea to skip Chirstmas this year - no tree, no gifts, no Christmas parties, etc. - and take a cruise instead. They would actually be saving money considering Christmas cost them over $6,000 the previous year. Their friends and neighbors don't take too well to their idea, however, and many hijinks ensue.

    This is only the second book I've read by Grisham. I didn't like the first one (The Appeal) at all, but I found this one rather enjoyable. It has everything you want in a light holiday read. It's charming, funny, and manages to get the point of the holiday season across very well. I can see me recommending it to my friends in the future.


    tagged "family" - 2 pts.
    tagged "satire" - 3 pts.
    review - 5 pts.
    same genre (comedy/humor) - 1 pt.
    additional bond (both books have been made into movies) - 1 pt.

    Total - 12 pts.
    Previous total - 54 pts.
    Grand Total - 66 pts

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • Play Book Tag Shelf

    Play Book Tag Shelf 

    12-28-09 Shelf is updated.

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • LibraryCin

    LibraryCin 

    will cross-post to the non-month tag thread

    Dewey the Small Town Library Cat Who Touched the World / Vicki Myron, Bret Witter
    4.75 stars.

    In January, 1988, a tiny long-haired orange kitten was found, freezing, in the book drop at the Spencer Public Library in Spencer, Iowa. The library director, Vicki Myron, decided to take care of the kitten, and have him live in the library. Dewey was a perfect library cat, who adored people! He lived at the Spencer Public Library for 19 years. This is his story.

    I am a librarian and a cat person. I loved the book! Dewey is absolutely adorable! In addition to the stories surrounding Dewey, the author also includes information about her own life, as well as about the farming community of Spencer, Iowa. I grew up in a small town on the Canadian prairies, so I actually found it kind of interesting and could relate. And because I like reading biographies, I was o.k. with Myron’s story, as well. I didn’t find those parts quite as interesting as the stories about Dewey, however, which is why I’ve docked it the ¼ star.

    Tag (family) = 2 points
    Review = 5 points
    Link: f) set in the same country (USA) = 1 point
    Total = 8 points

    Running total = 46 points

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • Play Book Tag Shelf

    Play Book Tag Shelf 

    12-29-09 Shelf is updated.

    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • ghost of a rose

    ghost of a rose (edited)

    I read Cold Comfort Farm, by Stella Gibbons (233 pages)
    My rating for this book: 4 stars
    (cross-posted to the "satire" thread)

    Cold Comfort Farm is about a young London woman who finds herself orphaned and destitute at the age of 20. She must go to live with a bunch of redneck relatives she has never met on their rundown farm in the country. Flora decides to make to best of the situation by improving the farm and everyone involved with it.

    The novel is a parody of the romanticized, sentimental glorifications of pastoral life that were so recently (when the book was written) wildly popular during the Victorian era. The farm is dark, dirty, and dreary; and its inhabitants not only dirty and dreary but also lethargic, mean, and stupid. The animals are ill and underfed, too. At first I had a hard time getting through the book even though it is fairly short, because I found it depressing. The awfulness is meant to be funny - and it is - but Gibbons does such a great and thorough job of describing it that it becomes almost desolate.

    (Spoiler alert) . . .

    . . .

    . . .

    However, the book gets lighter and lighter as it goes along and Flora makes her improvements, ending on a note of happily-ever-after.

    I was rather disappointed that we never get to find out what the "something nasty in the woodshed" was that Great Aunt Ada saw!

    I actually didn't like Flora all that much. I found her to be an annoying, interfering busybody who (as little more than a child and city-bred to boot) thinks that she knows best how her (older and with generations of experience) relatives should live their lives and run their farm. I kept waiting for Flora to get her comeuppance, for her schemes to fall apart. I've had personal experience with people who think they know what's best for someone else, and it ended catastrophically for the person who was interfered-with. But that never happens in this story. Flora's plots all turn out for the best and make everyone happy. I guess that's the way it has to be for this book to be a comic satire - that the city person does know best. If it had ended badly, the book would be a moral tale instead - a completely different kind of book. Still, I think that it would have given both Flora's character and the book as a whole much more depth and realism.

    . . .

    . . .

    . . . (End of spoilers)

    But since that's not the point, Cold Comfort Farm does succeed as comic satire. It's very well-written, and, taken as a whole, fun to read. The book is set "sometime in the near future" and has an occasional surprising element of science fiction. such as the amazingly prescient video telephones. The starred passages add an extra humorous touch. (They are starred to mark paragraphs of exceptional lyricism and beauty - i.e., hilariously over-the-top, pretentiously mixed metaphors, and overblown language.) And it's a great snapshot of British farm life almost a hundred years ago.

    I did have a bone to pick with the cover illustration. The hair colors of the two women don't match up with the clothing and mannerisms of the corresponding character as described in the text. It makes it confusing as to which woman in the picture is which character. It's a minor thing, and certainly has nothing to do with the text of the novel, but it is annoying. Otherwise it's a great illustration that perfectly matches the tone of the story.

    ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    Round 6:
    "family" tag: 2 points
    "satire" tag: 3 points
    review: 5 points

    links to The Painted Veil, by W. Somerset Maugham: 1 point
    - set in the same country, England (The Painted Veil is set in both England and China)

    creative link: 1 point
    - both were published in the early 1930's


    TOTAL FOR THIS ROUND: 12 points
    GRAND TOTAL: 61 points

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • againstthetide

    againstthetide 

    Points totaled through here.

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • Jen M

    Jen M 

    Here on Earth by Alice Hoffman
    Rating: 2.5 stars (rounded up to 3 stars)

    Review: March Murry returns to her childhood home to attend the funeral of the woman who raised her. She brings her teenaged daughter, Gwen, along but leaves her husband behind. Resentful of being pulled away from her friends, Gwen is sullen and angry, so it takes her a bit to start seeing what others notice so quickly: March is "taking up" with that boy again, her childhood sweetheart that everyone else said was bad news. As the story develops, it becomes complicated...one aspect weaving a portrait of a poor abused boy and the only love he's ever known, the other telling a story of the cruel, ruthless man he's become and the danger March has placed herself in.

    To make things even more complicated, there is the teenage boy Gwen is starting to love, the horse she wants to rescue, the crazy man in the swamp who might be related to her, the judge who is an old friend of the family and might be something more...the threads in this tapestry are very tangled indeed.

    Although I liked the Gwen story and appreciated Hoffman's writing style, I was honestly so irritated by the two main characters (March and her lover) that I found it really hard to like the book overall. I had no sympathy for her at all, and as the book progressed, my apathy actually became disgust at some point. I suppose some people can dislike the main character of a book and still enjoy the book but I was just irritated.

    Previous rounds - +52
    Tag - "family" +2
    Review - +5
    Additional links to previous book - Love and Marriage by Bill Cosby +2
    f) Location: Both take place in the United States
    g) Creative link: Both books are three word titles

    Total through round 6 = 71

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • Play Book Tag Shelf

    Play Book Tag Shelf 

    1-5-10 Shelf is updated.

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • Nicole R

    Nicole R 

    Points recorded through this point - 01/05/2010

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • Cora R

    Cora R (edited)

    Shadow Country - Peter Matthiessen

    4 1/2 stars (912 pages)

    Shadow Country is three books in one. Each book tells the same story, but from a different point of view. The story is historical fiction about E.J. Watson, a legendary sugar farmer in turn of the century Florida. The book takes place in a Florida that was as wild as the western frontier. E.J. Watson had a sugar plantation in the Ten Thousand Islands on the Western coast of Florida. Watson had a reputation for being a ruthless killer, most prominent was the rumor of "Watson Payday" where he was said to kill his field hands at the end of harvest so he wouldn't have to pay them. The first book in the novel (which has been previously published as a stand alone novel called Killing Mister Watson) tells the story of Watson from the point of view of his neighbors who eventually gun down Watson and claim self defense (this is not a spoiler as it is revealed in the prologue). In this section the reader sees the myth of Watson growing, but you are not sure what is truth and what is purely rumor. The second book (previous published as a stand alone called Lost Man's River) follows Watson's son Lucious who eight years after his father was killed is trying to find out the truth about his father. In this book, Lucious and the reader uncover some answers, but much is still unclear. The third book is written in the voice of Watson, who if telling his own story. In this section, many of the questions remaining are answered, although as a reader I was not sure how much to trust what Watson was telling me.

    I really enjoyed reading this novel. I learned a lot about Florida history and the everglades. The story talks about people making their living hunting plume birds and gators and how fast the populations were depleted so people had to find other ways to survive. I also found it interesting to explore how a man's life became a legend, even while he was still alive. It took awhile to get into the book because there were so many characters to keep straight in the first book, but once I got a feel for who was who I became wrapped up the mystery of perception and truth.

    Tag: families (I know the plural of the tag was OK on other weeks, if this is not OK let me know and I will find a new book) +2
    Review: +5
    Links (I have to wait until I read the book for week 5)

    Total Points So Far: 7

    Review is cross posted to Long Book Challenge and Non-Monthly Tag Reviews

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • againstthetide

    againstthetide 

    Scores tallied through this point.

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • Play Book Tag Shelf

    Play Book Tag Shelf 

    1-25-10 Shelf is updated.

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • Diane P

    Diane P (edited)

    Like Water for Chocolate: A Novel in Monthly Installments with Recipes, Romances, and Home Remedies
    by Laura Esquival
    2 stars

    I'll be right up front about this book. I did not like it. Although I did like several of the recipes (hence the 2 stars), the book on the whole has a ridiculous plot. The story is of three daughters and their widowed mother. According to Mexican tradition, the youngest daughter is not allowed to marry, but instead must remain unwed and be at her mother's beck and call, 24/7. Her beloved, whom she cannot marry, has a solution. He will marry the sister of the enslaved one and be able to be near her. Multiple problems ensue.

    Like many hispanic novels, magical realism abounds. This situation goes on for about twenty years, as a married couple they have children, Tita's aura gives off magical vibes which affect her cooking and the dishes she cooks.
    Toward the end the married sister acquires some mysterious malady. This segment of the book really put me off
    as it was rather disgusting.

    I'd almost like to say the book is written tongue in cheek-almost like a satire. I am going to futher investigate this angle. I would really explain a lot to me.

    Tag: Family 2 points
    Monthly tag: Satire 3 points
    Review: 5 pts.

    Links:
    Word in both titles: Water 1 pt.
    creative link: both written by women: 1 pt.
    Total = 12 points
    previous=55 points
    New total=67 points

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • Mary B

    Mary B 

    Little Children - Tom Perrotta
    4 stars

    This takes place in a very dull and typical suburban town; the characters introduced are all at least somewhat dissatisfied with their lives which drives them to do odd things. Sarah and Todd have an affair. Sarah's husband, Richard, develops an unhealthy relationship with a website and a pair of mail-order pre-worn panties. Todd's friend, Larry, takes his grief over shooting an unarmed kid and turns it into an obsession with the freshly-released child molester in the neighborhood, Ronnie. Ronnie - well, Ronnie's got problems. This was a well-written portrait of suburbia. My favorite part was probably the very appropriate book club in which they read Madame Bovary. This was an enjoyable, memorable, quick read.

    Tag: Family - 2 pts
    Tag: Satire - 3 pts
    Review - 5 pts
    Creative link - both were written by men - 1 pt
    Total: 11 pts

    Grand Total: 70

    posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
  • againstthetide

    againstthetide 

    Points tallied through here.

    posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
  • To reply to this discussion, please sign in or join now.

Return to top