« more discussions

• 

  Two questions about Echo!

  New Title

  

  My reading group got together this week to discuss the book!
  
  We have two unresolved questions-
  
  1) How old is Young Ian?
  
  2) On pgs. 362-363, Brianna and Roger are looking through the collection of letters from Jamie and Claire. There is mention of a letter with handwriting that Bree doesn't recognize. They discuss whether Ian could write, and how Bree didn't know if he could or not. Blah blah blah. Does anyone out there think William wrote the letter to Bree? And, what did the letter say?
  
  2 1/2) Can the next book be done now? We can't wait for the next one!
  
  Any thoughts would be appreciated!

  Lea G started this discussion 3 years ago. ( reply | permalink )

• 

  Helen L 

  New Title

  

  It seems to me that Young Ian is 5-10 years younger than Bree.

  I also hate waiting for the next installment!

  posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )

• 

  erika m 

  New Title

  

  Well, as far as the question on whether the handwriting could be William's, you could go back and look at the letter he wrote to Jamie in The Fiery Cross when he bought the astrolabe at Lord John's request for Jamie and had it made in gold. Just compare the way the letters are written, the flow of them and see if they are similar. Might give you something to speculate further with, like maybe William has reconciled later in the story to the truth of his parentage and is the one to take care of the box of letters so it can find its way to Bree and Roger?

  posted 2 years ago. ( permalink )

• To reply to this discussion, please sign in.

Return to top