For me, the appeal of McCaffrey is that she creates worlds that capture my imagination and characters that I care about. However, she was my entree into SF/Fantasy back in middle school, and on re-reads her prose strikes me as clunky, and I actually become less invested in her worlds and with her characters as her series' go on. So, for instance, I love the initial Pern trilogy (Dragonflight, Dragonquest, and The White Dragon) and I love the Harper Hall Trilogy (Dragonsong, Dragonsinger, and Dragondrums) but most of the other Pern books are dissatisfying. I love The Rowen and Damia, but I stopped reading the Tower and the Hive series pretty soon after those two. I love Freedom's Landing, but again gave up on the series after the second book. It got to the point that I kind of wished she were more like Robin McKinley, who never writes sequels despite the clamor of her fans.
posted 1 month ago. ( reply )