Books
Group avatar

Agatha Christie

If you love Agatha Christie please come and join us in discussing her wonderful works.

« more discussions

  • Tracey

    The Mysterious Affair at Styles group discussion

    Save Changes Cancel
    I hope everyone enjoyed reading The Mysterious Affair at Styles like I did. Now let's discuss.

    The questions are a mixture between what I found on the Internet and my own. Please add any questions or points that you wish to discuss.
    Tracey started this discussion 11 months ago. ( reply | permalink )

78

replies
expand replies 
Sign in to participate in this discussion.
  • Tracey

    Tracey (edited)

    Save Changes Cancel

    1. Did you figure out "whodunit"? How early on?

    posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    show 12 replies
    • jguidry

      jguidry (edited)

      Save Changes Cancel

      Nope. Everytime I read it I can't figure out if it was Lawrence or Alfred that did it. I knew one was framing the other, but I couldn't figure out which was which.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Connie
      Save Changes Cancel

      For most of the book, I was convinced that Mary Cavendish was the one who murdered her mother-in-law. I was suprised when Poirot announced the conspiracy between Alfred and Evelyn.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Jerseygirl / Dame Constance (Oodles) Oxford-Whapdoodle, D.C., B.C., D.C.A.
      Save Changes Cancel

      I read the book years ago but couldn't remember much about it. Part way through, I thought I remembered that Evelyn Howard was part of it but I kept thinking, "no, it can't be". I laughed when I discovered it was true.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Tracey
      Save Changes Cancel

      I honestly didn't think Evelyn was involved! Surprised me.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • AvidReader
      Save Changes Cancel

      I didn't have it figured out until the reveal. My thoughts had gone in the complete wrong direction.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Amie
      Save Changes Cancel

      I couldn't figure it out either. My suspicions kept changing with every new piece of evidence. I love that about her writing.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Jamie R
      Save Changes Cancel

      I already knew because my mean uncle had read the book first and took great delight in spoiling it for me...:(

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • jguidry
      Save Changes Cancel

      How rude! I hope you got him back eventually. ;0)

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Tracey
      Save Changes Cancel

      That is a mean uncle!

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Jamie R
      Save Changes Cancel

      I know:( and yes I got him back eventually with Silence of the Lambs.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Lottie Jane
      Save Changes Cancel

      I did figure it out. It made the most sense to me.

      posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Tracey
      Save Changes Cancel

      Well done!

      posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )
  • Tracey
    Save Changes Cancel

    2. Was there a twist that threw you?

    posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    show 4 replies
    • jguidry
      Save Changes Cancel

      I was thrown by the relationship between Alfred Inglethorpe and Evelyn Howard.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Tracey
      Save Changes Cancel

      I was thrown by the arrest of John Cavendish.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • jguidry
      Save Changes Cancel

      I didn't realize why Poirot was letting him get arrested. I thought it was to get the killer out of hiding, not to save his marriage.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • AvidReader
      Save Changes Cancel

      I'm with jguidry -- the reasons behind Poirot allowing Cavendish to get arrested surprised me.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
  • Tracey
    Save Changes Cancel

    3. How did you feel about the main characters? Did you connect with the characters in the book?

    posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    show 2 replies
    • Kris
      Save Changes Cancel

      I liked Hastings and found it funny when he liked a girl she would soon be found to be seeing someone else. I think it was neat to see things through his eyes - like Watson and Tom Buchanan (from The Great Gatsby).

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Lottie Jane
      Save Changes Cancel

      I also love Hastings and I love how Poirot always confounds. In addition, I like the relationship between the two of them. Hastings is always falling for some poor girl who is involved in a murder and Poirot is always admonishing him.

      posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )
  • Tracey

    Tracey (edited)

    Save Changes Cancel

    4. The only Agatha Christie books I have read have been in the third person. What did you think of the story in the first person?

    posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    show 9 replies
    • jguidry
      Save Changes Cancel

      First person can be a great method for storytelling if you choose the right character to play narrator. Hastings was a good bet. He is always there and Poirot explains everything to his friend. He also is a reactionary character who acts on impulse so Christie can use him to lead the reader down false paths.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • sfreeman
      Save Changes Cancel

      I enjoy the Poirot mysteries with Captain Hastings at the narrator - he is an excellent companion to Poirot and someone who is more approachable as a character.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Kris
      Save Changes Cancel

      I agree with both Jaret and sfreeman.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Jamie R
      Save Changes Cancel

      I think Hastings works out well as the narrator.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Tracey
      Save Changes Cancel

      I agree Hastings is a good narrator but I was initially surprised it was in first person. I did get use to it but I think I may prefer her books in the third person format.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Lottie Jane
      Save Changes Cancel

      I like Hastings as a narrator for the reasons listed above. If you are looking for the ultimate first person narration by Agatha Christie, I highly recommend The Murder of Roger Ackroyd.

      posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Tracey
      Save Changes Cancel

      I'm looking forward to reading it in August!

      posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )
    • winterslights
      Save Changes Cancel

      Me, too.

      posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )
    • jguidry
      Save Changes Cancel

      Already placed my hold at the library.

      posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )
  • Tracey
    Save Changes Cancel

    5. We are introduced to Poirot in this book. Can you give a few words to describe him?

    posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    show 7 replies
    • jguidry
      Save Changes Cancel

      funny, intelligent, arrogant

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Kris
      Save Changes Cancel

      haha, exactly, Jaret! I would add eccentric.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Tracey
      Save Changes Cancel

      And meticulous!

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Kris
      Save Changes Cancel

      Good one!

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • jguidry
      Save Changes Cancel

      yup, those fit, too.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Jamie R
      Save Changes Cancel

      Fussy, Intelligent and I have to agree with the above also. I always got the impression he was wealthy...

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Lottie Jane
      Save Changes Cancel

      Great list of words to describe Poirot

      posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )
  • Tracey
    Save Changes Cancel

    6. Hastings was a bit frustrated with Poirot a times, how do you think it would be to work with Poirot?

    posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    show 10 replies
    • jguidry
      Save Changes Cancel

      I'd be frustrated too. He gets very smug when he knows more than you do and seems to laugh at you while trying to make you puzzle it out. I'd have smacked him upside the head a few times. ;0)

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • winterslights
      Save Changes Cancel

      I think Poirot would drive me crazy!! He always knows more than you, but reveals very little. Until the denument (did I spell that correctly??? I mean the ending)

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • jguidry
      Save Changes Cancel

      It's not just that he doesn't reveal until the end. It's that he laughs at you because you didn't figure it out. That's why I'd have to slap him.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Kris
      Save Changes Cancel

      Totally! "What you don't see it by now?"

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Tracey
      Save Changes Cancel

      It made me laugh that he kept disappearing and then appearing but I could see how frustrating that would be!

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • winterslights
      Save Changes Cancel

      He can be terribly annoying, especially when you get the feeling he's being smug because he knows something we don't know or haven't figured out!

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Jamie R
      Save Changes Cancel

      I'd probably be impressed by how effective his methods were, but at the same time... I think he would drive me nuts! All that fussing and being Mr. Smarty Pants who always gets everything right...:)

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Tracey
      Save Changes Cancel

      Mr Smarty Pants.... Like it :-)

      posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )
    • winterslights
      Save Changes Cancel

      Great tag for a fussy man.

      posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Jamie R
      Save Changes Cancel

      :)

      posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )
  • Tracey
    Save Changes Cancel

    7. What did you think of Hastings?

    posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    show 6 replies
    • jguidry
      Save Changes Cancel

      Hastings was the stereotypical English male from that time period. A returning hero trying to figure out what to do with himself. A puffed up sense of chivalry combined with a naivete with the world around him especially a world that involves people he considers his friends. He has a mistrust for people considered "foreign" with the exception of Poirot. This is of course, I think, exactly what Christie wanted him to be. He's a great balance for Poirot.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • sfreeman
      Save Changes Cancel

      Hastings is one of my favorite Christie characters. He demonstrates what is most honorable and naive about the English "gentlemen" between the two world wars.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • winterslights
      Save Changes Cancel

      Hastings can be particularly dense at times. Then when Poirot shows him where he went wrong, he gets frustrated!!

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Jerseygirl / Dame Constance (Oodles) Oxford-Whapdoodle, D.C., B.C., D.C.A.
      Save Changes Cancel

      I like Hastings...for one thing, he's a Poirot fan, even if Poirot does frustrate him at times. And I agree with those above that he is the stereotypical English gentleman, focused on behaving in the most honorable way.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Kris
      Save Changes Cancel

      I like the difference between the two characters and think it make the story more enjoyable.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Jamie R
      Save Changes Cancel

      I like Hastings. He is the typical English gent, some features are dated / stereotypical, but I don't think there's anything wrong with that. Gentlemen like Hastings sadly don't really exist anymore! He's a great character, oddly comforting - he reminds me a bit of my Granddad and his friends!

      Kris - I totally agree with you about the differences making the story more enjoyable.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
  • Tracey
    Save Changes Cancel

    8. What did you think of the proposal made by Hastings?

    posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    show 4 replies
    • jguidry
      Save Changes Cancel

      Typical for his character. He saw a damsel in distress and could only think of one way to help her.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • sfreeman
      Save Changes Cancel

      It was the honorable thing for Hastings to do - exactly in character.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Kris
      Save Changes Cancel

      I agree with Jaret.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Tracey
      Save Changes Cancel

      Good way of expressing it Jaret.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
  • Tracey
    Save Changes Cancel

    9. This is the first book written by Christie. Do you think her works improve?

    posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    show 9 replies
    • jguidry
      Save Changes Cancel

      Hmm. Good question. They develop as the relationship between Poirot and Hastings develop and as Poirot adjusts to Hastings leaving. I can't say they get better though because I love them all.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • winterslights
      Save Changes Cancel

      I actually like the books that don't have Poirot or Miss Marple. I think she really creates situations that are really mind-twisting!!

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Kris
      Save Changes Cancel

      This is my first actual book of Christie's but I imagine it does as they seem popular even now.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Tracey
      Save Changes Cancel

      Really Kris! Why did I think you had read Christie before?

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Kris
      Save Changes Cancel

      Probably b/c I have so many of her books! Lol. I am glad that I finally got the motivation to actually read a novel. Thanks, Tracey!

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • AvidReader
      Save Changes Cancel

      I can't comment either, since it was my first Christie novel, too :-) I will admit that I wasn't overly impressed with the book, so I assume her novels get better and that is the reason for her enormous fan base.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Jamie R

      Jamie R (edited)

      Save Changes Cancel

      I quite liked this book, but its not in my top ten, so I definitely think her wok improves, especially the development of Poirot as a character - I think Poirot becomes more of a likeable character in the later works, to me he just didn't seem as charismatic in this as in later books. Strong development of characters, that grow with the reader are becoming rare in modern fiction.

      However, in fairness - I read this book a long time ago,I'd already read a few of the later books when I read this for the first time and found them more enjoyable. This is one of the few I've only read once or twice, whereas some of her other books I've read countless times. I hope to find time to quickly re-read it for this task, I first read this when I was 14. It might be one of the books that I enjoy more with a bit of experience behind me!

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Tracey
      Save Changes Cancel

      Melissa - this was my thoughts for asking this question. It is definitely not my favourite of Christie's books but I have only read a handful so I wanted to see what the long time Christie fans thought!

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Lottie Jane
      Save Changes Cancel

      I definitely think her work improves. This book cannot compare to the depth of some her later works like And Then There Were None, The Murder of Roger Ackroyd, Death on the Orient Express, and Poirot's last story Curtain.

      posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )
  • Tracey
    Save Changes Cancel

    10. Rate and Review

    posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    show 4 replies
    • jguidry
      Save Changes Cancel

      4 stars

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • winterslights
      Save Changes Cancel

      I give it 4.5 stars. As to a review, that's not my forte, I leave that to the rest of you.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Kris
      Save Changes Cancel

      4 STARS "In her first published mystery, Agatha Christie introduces readers to the heroic detective, Hercule Poirot. This is a classic murder mystery set in the outskirts of Essex. The victim is the wealthy mistress of Styles Court. The list of suspects is long and includes her gold-digging new spouse and stepsons, her doctor, and her hired companion." (From Amazon)

      I liked the narrator Hastings's point of view and Poirot's eccentric ways. A fun cozy mystery!

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
    • Jamie R
      Save Changes Cancel

      I gave it three stars on my shelf. I will try to post a review later.

      posted 11 months ago. ( permalink )
  • Lottie Jane
    Save Changes Cancel

    I gave it four stars. I enjoyed the murder mystery and the characters but it was not as complicated as some of her other work.

    posted 10 months ago. ( permalink )
  • To reply to this discussion, please sign in.

Return to top