Books
Group avatar

Favorite Fantasy

Let fellow Shelfarians know what you consider good fantasy novels.
  • Category: Genres | Started February 2007

« more discussions

  • Camerron W

    What are you reading? (November 2009)

    I just finished Elantris by: Brandon Sanderson.
    Camerron W started this discussion 2 months ago. ( reply )

26

replies
expand replies 
Sign in to participate in this discussion.
  • Camerron W

    Camerron W 

    Alright, so I just finished Elantris by: Brandon Sanderson.

    I must say it is wonderfully done and I really enjoyed this book. As a stand-alone novel I'm excited for it to be my first and I think he wrapped everything up nicely. The beginning was a touch rough but by the end he had the story moving along nicely. This book is going up as one of my favorites.

    I am about to start Mistborn by Sanderson as well, which I have heard is better than Elantris!

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • Tim F

    Tim F 

    I'm still reading The Gathering Storm. I am loving it so far, I just wish I had more time to read it.

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • cpauley929

    cpauley929 

    I'm going to start Sunshine by Robin McKinley as soon as I get it from the library.

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
    show 8 replies
    • PhoenixFalls

      PhoenixFalls 

      I hope you enjoy it! I've been a big fan of McKinley for a few years and while Sunshine took me a couple reads to really get a feel for (it's kind of unique in her cannon) it now ranks as one of my absolute favorites.

      posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
    • WonderBunny

      WonderBunny 

      I'm interested to see what you think Cp.

      The constant internal monolog of the main character drove me nuts. Also, McKinley's blog was annoying to when I went to look at that. She likes footnotes (in a blog! Rarrr).

      posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
    • PhoenixFalls

      PhoenixFalls 

      LOL, I can't stand the footnotes either! It would be one thing if her webmaster made each footnote a link, with a handy little "return to post" button afterwards, but all that scrolling back and forth is MADDENING.

      I really hated the internal monologue my first time through Sunshine, but like I said, after a couple more readings (because somehow I got around to craving it) it really started to work for me. Still, I definitely get why a lot of people (especially people who were fans of McKinley pre-Sunshine) think Sunshine is one of her weaker works.

      posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
    • cpauley929

      cpauley929 

      Well, I have it. Just picked it up. I'm not at all far enough into it to give you my impressions yet, but it fits really well for the challenge I'm doing at PBT, so I'll read it whether it's good or not. Already, I'm having a hard time keeping characters straight.

      posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
    • cpauley929

      cpauley929 

      I'm right there with you WB. The story has SO MUCH potential, but I find myself rolling my eyes at the page long digressions. It's so unnecessary, I can't hardly stand it. I'll finish the book, because the story (when she gets around to telling it) is good. I sincerely hope McKinley's other books aren't the same. I hate reading a hella long book, when it's not at all necessary for it to be that long. I feel like I'm wasting so much time.

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    • PhoenixFalls

      PhoenixFalls 

      None of McKinley's other books are like Sunshine. . . sorry to hear you hated it, and I'd recommend definitely NOT trying Dragonhaven because even I didn't like Dragonhaven, but if you want to give her another try try The Hero and the Crown or The Blue Sword. Both are extremely lean stories, absolutely nothing in there that isn't necessary.

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    • Beth C

      Beth C 

      I agree. The Hero and the Crown and The Blue Sword are great. They are lean (well put, Phoenix Falls), and well written. I also loved Deerskin--not for the squeamish. It does involve rape/incest. But, it really is about survival.

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    • cpauley929

      cpauley929 

      I haven't yet finished Sunshine. I will continue to read. It's not so much about hating it (if I really really hated it, I'd stop reading), it's more just the frustration with unnecessary, and uninteresting digression. It doesn't enhance the story, and only makes me skip paragraphs, which I almost never do. I'm hoping the end of the story will redeem the reading.

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
  • PhoenixFalls

    PhoenixFalls 

    I'm not reading a ton this month, as I'm trying to do NaNoWriMo. I am writing a fantasy novel for that though. . . so maybe that counts? ;)

    What little time I do have for reading should also be taken up by the SF Reading Challenge (if any of you are interested, we have a group here on Shelfari), but I doubt I'll be able to resist reading Robin McKinley's new collection of stories with her husband (Peter Dickinson) called Fire: Tales of the Elemental Spirits. And of course, to get in the mood for that release, I had to reread Sunshine, Chalice, and Spindle's End at the beginning of the month. . . :)

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
    show 2 replies
    • Beth C

      Beth C 

      I am in the mood for a Robin Mckinley--something along the lines of Deerskin, The Hero and The Crown/The Blue Sword--got a suggestion? Also, How do you like Dickinson? I bought The Rope, but haven't yet read it.

      posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
    • PhoenixFalls

      PhoenixFalls (edited)

      Hehe, I don't have a clue how I like Dickinson, as I bought The Ropemaker as well and haven't gotten to it yet. :) I will say, I thought his stories were weaker than McKinley's in the Water collection, but I still enjoyed them.

      As for what to read that's long those lines. . . there isn't anything else in her cannon that's like Deerskin. Which is maybe a good thing, because while Deerskin was incredible, it was also incredibly harrowing. . . the first time I read it I cried through the entire novel. (And I'm not usually THAT weepy. . .)

      The Hero and the Crown and The Blue Sword are both earlier works of hers, and kind of pared down, so if you liked the style of them you might enjoy Beauty, her first retelling of the Beauty and the Beast fairy tale. If you want something a little bigger, give Rose Daughter (her second retelling of Beauty and the Beast) or Spindle's End (her retelling of Sleeping Beauty) a try. . . though I warn you, some people thought both of them could have been written more tightly. I personally loved how much more world-building went into both of those, but some people prefer when all the world-building is implied as it is for the Damar stories.

      You could also give Chalice a try; it's her most recent novel, and the first 3/4 of it reminded me very much of The Hero and the Crown; unfortunately, the climax kind of falls apart, so overall I don't think it's one of her strongest.

      posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • Beth C

    Beth C 

    I'm reading the Bloody Jack series, by L.A. Meyer--on the third book--Under the Jolly Roger. They are well written and full of adventure. they are a historical fiction coming of age series about a young orphaned cockney girl who is full of moxy and talent.

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • jerry-book

    jerry-book 

    I just picked up Ariel.

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • WonderBunny

      WonderBunny 

      I picked that up recently too. Haven't gotten to it yet but I'm hoping for some reading time next month (because this month is crazy with my classes).

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
  • Tim F

    Tim F 

    I just finished up The Gathering Storm and loved it. I can't wait for the last two books. I am now on to The Way of Shadows by Brent Weeks.

    posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
  • WonderBunny

    WonderBunny 

    I've been reading more urban fantasy this month. I would like to get to a few fantasy books though.

    posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
  • Robin M

    Robin M 

    Has anyone read Heart of the Ronin/ Travis Heermann? I've heard it's comparable to the Tales of the Otori/Lian Hearn that I really liked.

    posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
  • WriterDan

    WriterDan 

    Read Gathering Storm. Didn't hate it. Mostly frustrated me. At least we get the story though, even if the telling of it is nowhere near as good. And there are still the parts to be had that WERE written by Jordan. They were awesome.

    Read Water for Elephants (not fantasy, divergence I know). Not that great. No real story. Mostly just a historical snippet in my opinion.

    Reading House of Suns. Good, but long and dense.

    Next up on my docket is the first three books of the Malazan series. Friends of mine keep harping on me that they're awesome, but you have to give the series at least three books before you really understand what is going on. It's taken forever for me to get here, but I think I'm finally ready to give the time necessary to these books this time through. Committed!

    posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
  • Camerron W

    Camerron W 

    Alright well I just finished Mistborn and am about to start The Well of Ascension both by Brandon Sanderson.

    Mistborn is a great followup book after Elantris. He did a wonderful job with character development as well as using a very unique magic system. I highly reccommend this book and hopefully I will be able to say the same about the entire series.

    I also have started DragonFlight =]

    posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
  • Tim F

    Tim F 

    I just finished The Way of Shadows by Brent Weeks and really enjoyed it. I'm planning on reading the rest of The Night Angel trilogy next. After that I am hoping to find more gritty fantasy. Any suggestions?

    posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    show 2 replies
    • WriterDan

      WriterDan 

      Gritty? Have you read Joe Abercrombie? He outshines the lot in the "gritty" fantasy genre.

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    • Tim F

      Tim F 

      I haven't tried him yet, but he is on my TBR list and I'm getting to him faster than I thought I would.

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
  • Tim F

    Tim F 

    Finished The Way of Shadows and moved directly into Shadow's Edge by Brent Weeks. I'm really enjoying this series so far. I hope the rest of book two and then book three are just as good as what I have read so far.

    posted 3 weeks ago. ( reply )
  • To reply to this discussion, please sign in or join now.

Return to top