Books
Group avatar

Favorite Fantasy

Let fellow Shelfarians know what you consider good fantasy novels.
  • Category: Genres | Started February 2007

« more discussions

  • LaserWraith

    Your Favorite Coming of Age Books

    The coming of age category is one of my favorites.

    So could you please list your favorite coming for age books here, along with answers to these questions:

    *Protagonist male or female?
    *Any adult content?
    *What were the abilities the protagonist got?


    I'm not sure about you, but I also view books where the protagonist didn't have powers, and then got some (by a different reason then "growing up," like in Eragon's case, becoming a dragon rider) as "coming of age".
    LaserWraith started this discussion 2 months ago. ( reply )

17

replies
expand replies 
Sign in to participate in this discussion.
  • PhoenixFalls

    PhoenixFalls (edited)

    Nobody's Son, by Sean Stewart. Male protagonist, very minor adult content (the kind that would go over a kid's head), and he didn't get abilities.

    The Hero and the Crown, by Robin McKinley. Female protagonist, no adult content, and she became immortal and gained magic.

    The Heritage of Hastur, by Marion Zimmer Bradley. Male protagonist, mild adult content, and he develops telepathy.

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
    show 2 replies
    • LaserWraith

      LaserWraith 

      "...and he didn't get abilities."


      So how did he "come of age"?

      posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
    • PhoenixFalls

      PhoenixFalls 

      He grew up. He became an adult. That's the hallmark of a coming-of-age novel to me. . . the abilities are just the usual fantasy way of marking that transition.

      There is magic in the novel, but no sorcerers, so there weren't any powers for him to come into. He took a wife, became a lord, fought in a climactic battle, but the transition was simply from a teenager's mindset of self-involvement to an adult's mindset of community building and thinking of others in addition to himself.

      posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • Mark W

    Mark W 

    "A Spell For Chameleon" by Piers Anthony is my absolute favorite. In Xanth, everyone has magic except for Bing (male protagonist). Once you reach a certain age if you haven't discovered your magic talent you are banished to the country of Mundane (which looks a lot like Florida). This is the story of Bing searching for his magic and what happens when he does (or doesn't) find it.

    No adult content, safe for all ages, fantastic story.

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • Beth C

    Beth C 

    Taran Wanderer, by Lloyd Alexander. It is a male protagonist who is on a journey to both find out who he is and become a hero. It reminded me of The Alchemist (though I liked it better).
    I love the message--The answer is often within, as opposed to external options.
    I too loved the Hero and the Crown, as well as The Blue Sword, both female coming of age, and developing abilities unbeknownst to the main characters.

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • Gribshnobler

    Gribshnobler (edited)

    Well, I'm currently reading the Earthsea books by Ursula K. LeGuin (on the 5th one right now), and coming of age seems to be the theme of all the books (that and , you're never too old to grow further).

    they're all great, but so far the one that I can relate to the most is the first "A Wizard of Earthsea", which is (symbolically at least) about facing the darkness within yourself, and realizing that you can't simply defeat it. You can't let it overpower or control you, but you still have to utilize it as part of yourself to become a full person. A much more realisitic and interesting concept than plain old good or bad IMO. This novel features a male protagonist, but the series as a whole features both men and women as the main characters, depending on which entry you read.

    The first 3 books are suitable for ages 10 and up. The latter 3 were mildly controversial as they entail a much more feminist counterpoint to the previous 3 and do feature more adult content, including some somewhat disturbing moments. Some people didn't care for this stylistic change, but I think it's clever how LeGuin turned the tables on her own work, and personally I feel it only makes the world of Earthsea that much richer.

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • bjgryphon

    bjgryphon 

    Jaxom in the Pern books comes immediately to mind but my favorite is Talia in Lackey's Valdemar (Arrows trilogy) series. The female character was so clueless about companions and any powers she might have. It was kind of a classic underdog tale - poor fisher folk girl comes to big city and feels out of place and less than. The first book is, I think, ok for middle school readers on up. The content gets more adult as books go on - i.e., torture and violent death. In some ways it's also a classic quest story.

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • Matthew C

    Matthew C 

    the books i would suggest would be The Belgariad by David Eddings. the main character is a teenage boy. oh yeah, hes also a budding sorcerer. there are some very minor adult references in some of the later books.

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • LaserWraith

    LaserWraith 

    Thanks for all the suggestions. I'm checking them out.

    Matthew C: It is very interesting that the Inheritance Cycle (you recommended that in another group) and Belgarath the Sorcerer are my most favorite books! :)

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • Garrett S

    Garrett S 

    Umm... I don't know. Does The Song of Ice and Fire count? Harry Potter too, I guess. Other than that, most C-o-A don't really appeal to me.

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
    show 3 replies
    • Camerron W

      Camerron W 

      No I don't believe the song of ice and fire would count in this case.. there is too much violence in it for LaserWraith i think

      posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
    • Tim F

      Tim F (edited)

      Personally I like A Song of Ice and Fire as a coming of age story. Yes it covers many adult themes and is very gritty fantasy, but I enjoy watching the Stark children grow and change, maturing into the people who will rule the Seven Kingdoms (if they live that long, Martin is a bit trigger happy in killing off characters).

      posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
    • Camerron W

      Camerron W 

      I agree with you Tim! I am with everyone else anxisouly awaiting ADWD. LaserWraith however had said when I reccommended the Terry Goodkinds' Sword of Truth SEries in a different discussion to him, said he had reviewed it and there was too much sex and violence or adult content... Thats why i'm betting some stuff in A Song of Ice and Fire won't make the cut for him.

      posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • cpauley929

    cpauley929 

    Graceling by Kristin Cashore was a great coming of age story. It's about a young girl, Katsa, who is discovered to be one of the Graced, a person with special abilities beyond that of your average person. Katsa has the Grace of Killing. She learns a lot about herself, and comes into her powers, as well as herself as a person throughout the book. It's a teen book. There is some romance, but only in the most tame sense. The book is not about the romance, but about the characters plight, and what they must do to overcome adversity.

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • Archmage

    Archmage 

    Magician by Raymond E Feist
    Two boys growing up in a remote castle when a war breaks out. One finds magical armour and becomes the greatest warrior in the land and the other discovers his own magical potential to become the most powerful Magician. First read it when I was about 12 or 13 and although there is a war going on, it's pretty tame content wise.

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • JenineW

    JenineW 

    The Tamir Trilogy by Lynn Flewelling. Because of a curse/prophesy that a woman would always rule a usurper king kills all royal girls born. The rightful heir bears boy/girl twins and wizards use their power to exchange the dead boy's gender for the girls. The story follows the girl as she grows into her position and discovers her true gender and self. She also falls in love with her squire along the way but this is much more of a sub-plot. In the first book "The Bone Dolls Twin" the beginning bothered me because of the brother's murder/death but that was the only part of the trilogy that really disturbed me. Overall there is some fantasy violence and awareness of sex but nothing is overly graphically described or what I'd call adult content.

    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • Dave H

    Dave H 

    "The Fourth Realm Travelers Series" by John Twelve Hawks, "The Rangers Apprentice Series" by John Flanagan (younger teens), "The Farseer Trilogy" and "Tawny Man Trilogy" by Robin Hobb, "The Kingkiller Chronicles Trilogy" by Patrick Rothfuss, "The First Law Trilogy" by Joe Abercrombie, "The Night Angel Trilogy" by Brent Weeks (older teens & adults). Merry Christmas and READ ON...

    posted 3 days ago. ( reply )
  • To reply to this discussion, please sign in or join now.

Return to top