Group avatar

Graphic Novels/Comics

I thought this group would be a good place to expose each other to great graphic novels that are out there. We can add them to the group shelf and put a comment in the 'discuss' area about why you thought it was good. I'll start by putting a bunch of graphic novels that I thought were really good, and should be read.
  • Category: Genres | Started Friday, February 9 2007

« more discussions

  • NYC Strong

    Top 3 Graphic Novels that Everybody should read

    If you were suggest 3 graphic novels that somebody should read what would they be. In other words your 3 greats.

    My humble opinion:
    1. Watchmen
    2. Maus
    3. Astro City
    NYC Strong started this discussion 1 year ago. ( reply )

96

replies
expand replies 
Sign in to participate in this discussion.
  • Somnium

    Somnium 

    hmmm...this is hard

    1. Sandman
    2. Maus
    3. V for Vendetta

    (with Transmetropolitan a close 4th)
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • NYC Strong

      NYC Strong 

      I know it's bad, but when they make a movie out of the novel before I had a chance to read it I can't bring myself to, but I really should read V for Vendetta.
      posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • npal

    npal 

    In no particular order: The Sandman Chronicles, Billy Corrigan: Smartest Kid on Earth, Bone.
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • DOC-209

      DOC-209 

      Hi. Just joined this group; I humbly suggest the following three:

      1. The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen (WAAAAAY better than the movie)
      2. Danger Girl
      3. Arrowsmith (an excellent fantasy/alternate history yarn)
      posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • NYC Strong

    NYC Strong 

    You should throw them on the shelf. Anybody with something different and good should throw it on the shelf. I always search the shelf to see what interesting novels you guys put up there. I just finished Identity Crisis. It's by no way a top 3, but I threw it up there because it was really well done. It has some truly captivating moments.
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • DOC-209

      DOC-209 

      I have taken your advise and put my three choices on the group shelf. (Just for good measure, I put both volumes of The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen on the shelf...which probably counts as four titles but I wanted to be thorough).
      posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • esmeralda

    esmeralda 

    Maus
    Y: the last man
    Sandman
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • sweetafton

    sweetafton 

    Hi there, I just found this group. Fantastic. Let's see, right now my top three are:
    1. Hadashi no Gen (Barefoot Gen) by Nakazawa, any volume, really.
    2. Transmetropolitan by Ellis--I am a sucker for Spider Jerusalem, even bought the action figure.
    3. Watchmen... I almost forgot this and put Blankets here, but as much as I like Craig Thompson, Watchmen is classic.
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • bookdreamer

    bookdreamer 

    1. American Splendor
    2. Need More Love (has some regular text/photos in it, too)
    3. Love and Rockets (I think that's what it's called, the big book)

    I read one Sandman but didn't really like it, sorry everyone!
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • ckirby

    ckirby 

    For me, the first two are no-brainers:

    1. Watchmen
    2. Maus (sorry to be so predictable)

    It's the third that I think really sets each of these lists apart, and I've really struggled for a good third choice.

    3. Kingdom Come
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
    show 2 replies
    • themessiers

      themessiers 

      Although I haven't been reading them for long (except for TINTIN), I would suggest the following:

      Blankets
      Bone
      V for Vendetta
      posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
    • sweetafton

      sweetafton 

      Your third choice is awesome, so the struggle was worthwhile. ;)
      posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • NYC Strong

    NYC Strong 

    I would like to change my Astro City selection to Y: The Last Man. This series just rules. More exciting then an Indiana Jones movie. I always get that epic adventure feeling while I read them. The series is almost done. Right now it is up to 56 out of 60.
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • michael

      michael 

      The Sandman particularly Season of Mists and The Kindly ones
      The Dark Knight - Frank Miller

      struggling for the third hahaha choosing between 300, Watchmen and Y the Last Man the ending was great!!!
      posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • Jolly Bengali

    Jolly Bengali 

    Seems like Watchmen is on almost everyone's list (which isn't surprising at all). Many also mentioned V For Vendetta. Again, it deserves to be on the top list obviously. I'll try to list top 3 non-obvious graphic novels.

    1. The Seven Crystal Balls + Red Reckahms Treasure (Tintin) - Herge

    The story is divided into two books, and you have to read both of them to get the 'full-flavor'. Herge's drawing is , of course, fantastic. Even though some may find his drawing style a little too old school. As for the story, the humor is aplenty, and so is the suspense/mystery. Unfortunately, if you are not familiar with all the regular characters in Tintin books already, you may not get every joke. It's still worth a read though.

    2. Marvels -Kurt Busiek

    This one tells the history of all superheroes ( Marvel superheroes at least) from the perspective of a photographer who has been photographing superheroes from the very beginning.

    3. Top Ten - Alan Moore
    One of my most favorite. Unfortunately, it's not really a 'novel' as there is no central theme. But, if you want to know about the state-of-the-art of modern superhero comics, this is the one.
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • oliversourpuss

    oliversourpuss 

    - jimmy corrigan
    - locas (collected)
    - tiny giants
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • readingroomkatie

    readingroomkatie 

    hmm...i don't think i've read enough of them to give my top three. I've only just begun. however, i am enjoying the Sandman series.
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • Xgirl

    Xgirl 

    I'd probably say Watchmen, Sandman and Fables.
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • MrPerfect

    MrPerfect 

    Although I think Watchmen should be #1 on any list, I'll abstain from listing it...

    1.Kingdom Come
    2.Runaways
    3.Fables
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • cpauley929

      cpauley929 

      Yay Fables! Great fairy tale re-telling.
      posted 3 weeks ago. ( reply )
  • toolverine

    toolverine 

    From my collection:

    1. Guilty ( A Xeric Award winner)
    2. Ghost World
    3. Box Office Poison
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • readingroomkatie

      readingroomkatie 

      Tell me about Ghost World. What's that about? I've never heard of it. Who's it by?
      posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • Ivan_Isaacs

    Ivan_Isaacs 

    1. PREACHER
    Hands down this is IT. The best work by Garth Ennis and will NEVER be that good again. This had a great deal of violence but hardly for the sake of it. The story was awesome and intriguing.
    Steve Dillon's art and the coloring of Matt Hollingsworth and Pamela Rambo did their part, too.
    I'm looking forward to re-read it again.

    2. BREAKFAST AFTER NOON
    IMO Andi watson's best work to date. A story of a British couple and their ways of dealing with unemployment.

    3. BONE: ONE VOLUME
    Jeff Smith created a masterpiece. Simply as that. It has humor, likeable characters, action, drama, deaths et al. Sure one can get the impression that Smith lost a little bit of steam towards the end but still it's a phantastic read.
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
    show 3 replies
    • sweetafton

      sweetafton 

      I loved those few times that Ennis wrote a dog into the story, because Dillon cannot draw a dog to save his life. Preacher was my first and still has my heart in a pint glass.
      posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
    • LouanneJacobs

      LouanneJacobs 

      Just scrolled down to see if anyone mentioned Preacher. Yeah, you! Someone mentioned to me recently that they couldn't believe I loved that series so much since it is not a "girl" series - phooey! This girl loved it and the strongest girl character known.

      My top 3, h-m-m

      The classic and not-to-be-missed ones have been listed, so how about these additions:

      Yossel by Joe Kubert
      Auschwitz by Pascal Croci
      and American Born Chinese by Gene Yang (won the Printz Award this year)


      posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
    • SirePhobos

      SirePhobos 

      Odd. It was a girl that I once knew that got me to try and read The Preacher. I wish that I would have. She was Tulip, but I couldn't see it.
      posted 11 months ago. ( reply )
  • RoterPanda

    RoterPanda 

    Okay, I know its four, but I can't narrow it down any more. My picks, in alphabetical order, are:

    Epileptic
    From Hell
    Nausicaa
    New Frontier
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
    show 2 replies
    • nietoperz

      nietoperz 

      V For Vendetta
      Sandman (the whole thing, I'm afraid)
      Batman: Year One
      posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
    • jberns89

      jberns89 

      Epileptic is amazing. I am glad to see other people appreciate it as well.
      posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • deactivated member 


    1.) "Pride of Baghdad" --- Beautiful artstyle and the story is sad but moving.

    2.) "Maus" --- I feel that this book is a great way to introduce people (young and old) to the struggles and hardship that went on during the nazi era. It's very "not in your face" and even finds a way to make light of certain situations..

    3.) The "Fables" series --- Okay, so this one isn't as "serious" as the first two but it's definately worth a read if you'd like to see another side of the fairy tales we grew up reading :)
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • katfireblade

    katfireblade 

    In no particular order:

    Preacher -- Because it has a really interesting set of messages, not the least of which is the difference between religion and spirituality, and for one of the most kick ass heroines ever.

    Elfquest -- ALL the ones written by Richard and Wendy Pini directly, or, at least, the first 8. They have ideas in there that are downright subversive, and not a cuddily elf in sight.

    Fruitbasket -- No, no, bear with me. If you were EVER picked on in school or disassociated from your parents and the people around you and still carry scars, THIS is the series to look at. Past all the usual kiddie manga warm-fuzziness are some rather piercing insights. Its not the usual American schlep of "toughen up, learn to go it alone, just ignore them" but instead frequently calls bullshit on those very ideas. It might be the first thing, ever, that actually brought me right back to standing in those places again, and then told me what I actually needed to hear to make it all better, instead of the myths or lies. Full kudos to the authoress or whoever the heck she's talking to.
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • Zeph

    Zeph 

    here we go then:-

    1. The Sandman's tales. Gaiman is a genius, and this is probably the most satisfying set of books i have *ever* read.

    2. The authority. Love Ellis's take on the superhero genre, it was either this or Transmetropolitan for his futuristic foresight, he is very Zeitgeisty.

    3. Tank girl. Just love the humour, one of the best bits was her killing bounty hunters and doing celebrity impressions after each.
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • manello

    manello 

    Punisher: Circle Of Blood
    Hellboy Series
    Sock Monkey Series
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • Phexius

      Phexius 

      These are the 3 titles I always recommend to friends who assume comics/graphic novels are whimsical lightweight stories of "Good vs Evil" and want to pick up one to "kill time". lol I love the love/hate reaction they get... "omg this is unbelievable! and damn you for not giving me something mindless to read"

      Batman: Year One
      Sandman
      The Watchmen
      posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • bootsjr

    bootsjr 

    I would go with:

    Watchmen
    Preacher
    Batman: The Long Halloween
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • lizzieloo8

    lizzieloo8 

    hmm....i think watchmen is a given.

    so I would go with We3, i just loved it.
    Sin City (all of them), I just really enjoyed them.
    and Authority.

    with Sam & Twitch as a close 4th.
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • jberns89

    jberns89 

    This is very challenging but if I had to pick three I would go with
    1. Blankets
    2. Maus
    3. Complete Bone

    Although Marvels, Kingdom Come, American Born Chinese, Dark Knight Returns, and Epileptic are all close runners up.
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • brians

    brians 

    1. watchmen
    2. maus
    3. locas (ideally, l&r vols i-x, but ya know...)
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • Zer0_effect

    Zer0_effect 

    *Y: The Last Man. Outstanding story line, it is now up to 58 (which was big)
    *Crossing Midnight. Newer title but i have a feeling it is going to be an amazing story the first TPB just came out last month
    *100 Bullets. I was surprised no one else put this down. It may not be my actual # 3 but i think it deserves to be mentioned in the forum.
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
    show 2 replies
    • ILoveUFL

      ILoveUFL 

      I really enjoy 100 Bullets too. Every the new volume comes out, I always want to reread everything from the beginning.
      posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
    • Sofia Q

      Sofia Q 

      I LOVE the 100 Bullets series!
      posted 9 months ago. ( reply )
  • donopolis

    donopolis 

    I can't pick my top three ever. However I do need to bring up Miracle Man.
    Man Talk about groundbreaking. Alan Moore writing for Warrior Magazine in 1982.
    Neil Gaiman took over when he left and made his own unique mark...these books are out of print...I own the original comics if you can find them, do not hesitate.
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • khalidjaafar

    khalidjaafar 

    1. Maus
    2. The Rabbai's Cat
    3. The Plot
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • nunile

    nunile 

    My choice would be:
    1. Jimmy Corrigan, the smartest kid on earth of Chris Ware
    2. Ghostworld of Daniel Clowes
    3. El almanaque de mi padre, Barrio Lejano or anyone of Jiro Taniguchi

    Also:
    4. Lost bullets of David Lapham
    5. Black Hole of Charles Burns
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • Frank S

      Frank S 

      I think it's Stray Bullets by Lapham and you're right on... it's an awesome series.
      posted 9 days ago. ( reply )
  • nunile

    nunile 

    Mmmm, I also liked "Ice Haven" of Daniel Clowes a lot
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • SeanMK

    SeanMK 

    I'm going to suggest,

    The Invisibles
    Bone
    Transmetropolitan

    There are some other series that are still going that I love (Powers, Scott Pilgrim...) but I need to see how they end.
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • phTheDude

    phTheDude 

    1. Sandman
    2. Lucifer
    3. Hellboy (cheesy, but fun)
    Sorry, I can't help myself: 4. the Marvel Civil War series
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • kethry

    kethry 

    Aside from the usual Moore and Gaiman graphic novels:

    1. We3 - Grant Morrison story telling in this short sci-fi story was excellent - it was horrifying and so, so sad

    2. Identity Crisis - Greg Rucka effectively made me ask what would I have done if I was in the characters' shoes (and capes)?

    3. Batman: War Games - this was an event across all Batman-related comics and what was impressive was that the writing and even art (its theme and colors used) was consistent! It was a big achievement by the series editors.
    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • Chris P

      Chris P 

      "2. Identity Crisis - Greg Rucka effectively made me ask what would I have done if I was in the characters' shoes (and capes)?"

      You mean Brad Meltzer insread of Greg Rucka, right? (though the thought of what Rucka would have done with it intrigues me...)
      posted 11 months ago. ( reply )
  • ILoveUFL

    ILoveUFL 

    I just can't list three! So here are my top picks.

    Those compiled in a single volume:
    1. Watchmen (of course!) - fantastic writing
    2. Kingdom Come - beautiful artwork
    3. V for Vendetta - the movie didn't do the book justice

    Multiple-volume work:
    1. Lucifer
    2. Transmetropolitan
    3. Fables

    Bone was hilarious.


    posted 1 year ago. ( reply )
  • katsand1

    katsand1 

    The Sandman Series
    Preacher
    Kabuki

    (Flight and Y: The Last Man make the top 5)

    posted 12 months ago. ( reply )
  • Rick S

    Rick S 

    OK, everyone's already mentioned the obvious - Maus, Watchmen, etc., so I'll add some more off-the-beaten-track titles. Some background:

    Back in the 60s, a guy from Texas worked in the Texas Capitol building in the capitol press. In his spare time he self published some of the first hippie underground comix - kind of ironic they are called underground and the Capitol Press was located in the basement - they were called God Nose. He then moved on to San Francisco and co-founded Rip Off Press and was art director for Family Dog, the folks who produced all those glorious psychedelic posters. His name was Jack Jackson, and his pen name was Jaxon.

    He was an amateur historian, and after returning to Texas, he studied Texas history, and his own genealogy. He became well known as an historical illustrator, and wrote books about early Texas history.

    He also created several graphic novels - all in black and white - about Texas history.

    Commanche Moon, the story of Quanah Parker

    Los Tejanos - the Juan N. Sequin story


    Lost Cause: John Wesley Hardin, the Taylor-Sutton Feud, and Reconstruction Texas

    Indian Lover: Sam Houston & the Cherokees

    The Alamo: An Epic Told from Both Sides

    Now Jaxon's stories are totally historically accurate - they depict the clothing, buildings and most importantly the attitudes of the people and the times. He has been accused by some reviewers as being racist because of his use of terms of derision (the forbidden N word among others) and racial stereotyping. There is also nudity and of course violence. But the world he depicted was racist and violent.

    Jack was himself not racist (I knew him for years), and was in fact sympathetic to all the different peoples' points of view. Commanche Moon was from the Indian's point of view, Los Tejanos from the Spanish/Mexican settlers' point of view, and Lost Cause from the point of view of the post-Civil War southern anglo settlers. He wanted to do a tale of Texas from the point of view of the black settlers, maybe the Buffalo Soldiers, or the famous black cowboys, and was researching the subject when his health deteriorated.

    He sank into depression upon learning about his prostate cancer - he already suffered from extreme arthritis and diabetes - and ended his own life in 2006.

    I'll add these graphic novels to the reading list. They may not be everyone's cup of tea, but they are real, gutsey, and worth reading.
    posted 12 months ago. ( reply )
  • catalytic

    catalytic 

    With just 3...
    1. Y the last man
    2. Palestine by Joe Sacco
    3. Watchmen
    posted 12 months ago. ( reply )
  • meyoneyz

    meyoneyz 

    If I were to recommend the top 3 graphic novels one should have to read, that would be (well, so far):

    1. WATCHMEN - The best of the best, man, strikes really hard in the core! Hats off to Alan Moore and Dave Gibbons. The "Citizen Kane" of graphic novels for me.
    2. The Dark Knight Returns - an innovative masterpiece about Batman's later years by Frank Miller
    3. Kingdom Come - by Alex Ross and MArk Waid.
    posted 12 months ago. ( reply )
  • deactivated member 

    These changed my life as a kid and started the age of "comics just aren't for kids anymore"
    1. Watchmen
    2. Dark Night Returns
    3. Akira - I never saw such detailed cartooning until epic re-released this series, in color and in America.

    Another good one is "Hardboiled" by Jeff Darrow & Frank Miller. Blade Runner meets Akira. The drawing alone, blew my young impressionable mind.
    posted 11 months ago. ( reply )
  • Dave S

    Dave S 

    If we're talking series, it would be:
    1. Preacher
    2. Y: The Last Man
    3. Lucifer
    (With honorable mention to Transmetropolitan and The Walking Dead)

    If we're talking single volumes, it would be:
    1. Bone
    2. Blankets
    3. V for Vendetta.
    posted 11 months ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • Chris P

      Chris P 

      I'm going to go your route and separate series and one-shots, I think that'll make it easier for me.

      Series:
      - DMZ (I'm really surprised no one else has listed this!)
      - The Walking Dead
      - Y: The Last Man

      One-Shots
      - V for Vendetta
      - Kingdom Come
      - Watchmen

      Honorable Mentions
      - JLA, specifically the Joe Kelly/Doug Mahnke run (Golden Perfect, Obsidian Age, Rules of Engagement, Trial By Fire)
      - Sam & Twitch (Bendis' run)
      - Sleeper
      posted 11 months ago. ( reply )
  • deactivated member 

    I'm going to cheat a bit here because this is like Sophie's Choice:
    1. Brian K. Vaughan (Most of the things he touch just turn to gold: Y: The Last Man, Ex-Machina, Pride of Baghdad, Runaways and guiltily, yes, even the Faith arc of BtVS. Obviously, I have hard-on for Vaughan)
    2. The Sandman Series. Neil Gaiman cemented his status in graphic novel history.
    3. There was a toss up between Maus and Persepolis so as the votes were split, the 3rd goes to Chelsea Boys Steppin' Out. What an upset! :)
    posted 11 months ago. ( reply )
  • SirePhobos

    SirePhobos 

    1. The Preacher
    2. Transmetropoliton
    3. Johnny the Homicidal Maniac
    posted 11 months ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • cpauley929

      cpauley929 

      I'm so glad you put Johnny here! It's one of the funniest, most disturbing comics ever. I love goth social commentary.
      posted 3 weeks ago. ( reply )
  • sutirted

    sutirted 

    I shall go with some that have not been put on anyone's list yet.

    Mini's & Novels
    1. Contract With God
    2. Crisis on Infinite Earths
    3. The Crow

    Series
    1. Animal Man v1-3 (especially the 3rd volume)
    2. Powers (mentioned by SeanMK, but not in list proper)
    3. Exterminators (started out good and weird, seems to be getting a little off track but still good for now)
    posted 11 months ago. ( reply )
  • mmolino54

    mmolino54 

    1) City of Glass (graphic novel version of Paul Auster's book)
    2) Jimmy Corrigan
    3) Maus
    posted 10 months ago. ( reply )
  • Dan Tres  Omi

    Dan Tres Omi 

    good question... gosh
    1. V for Vendetta
    2. Walking Dead series
    3. Y: the Last Man series
    posted 10 months ago. ( reply )
  • Raghu

    Raghu 

    IMHO also,

    1. A Contract with God
    2. Maus
    3. Sandman : Endless nights

    posted 10 months ago. ( reply )
    show 2 replies
    • flipchip98

      flipchip98 

      For me its:

      1) Kingdom Come
      2) Watchmen
      3) 300
      posted 9 months ago. ( reply )
    • Jacob R

      Jacob R 

      1. Berserk!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
      2.300
      3. Berserk (again)!!!!!!!
      posted 9 months ago. ( reply )
  • deactivated member 

    The Crow
    Poison Elves: The Mulehide Years
    From Hell
    posted 9 months ago. ( reply )
  • Sofia Q removed this reply 9 months ago.
  • Sofia Q

    Sofia Q 

    I'm very new to the genre so my reading thus far is limited. Of what little I've read -- and these are all stand alone titles --my favorites are (in no particular order):

    1. V for Vendetta
    2. A History of Violence
    3. Road to Perdition

    But like I said, I have TONS to read. My tastes lean towards contemporary stories, crime tales and socio-political ideas. These elements appeal to me more than artwork. (I know, sacre bleu! Aren't we talking about a visual genre here? But hey, I'm a writer and come to these works as a novelist. In fact, I have picked up graphic novels that were adaptation of other works (e.g. Scanner Darkly) because I was intrigued by the ideas. Perhaps if I were a visual artist, my list might be different, who knows?

    As for as series goes, two are tied for my favorites: DMZ and 100 Bullets.
    posted 9 months ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • Frank S

      Frank S 

      Try Strangers in Paradise. I'm surprised it hasn't been mentioned yet...
      posted 9 days ago. ( reply )
  • Lucifal

    Lucifal 

    Marvel 1602 (neil Gaimen)
    The Dark Tower: The Gunslinger Born (Stephen King)
    Death and The Maiden (Richard Calder)
    But the latter won't be out until later this year! (ISBN 978-1-906584-00-9)
    posted 9 months ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • cpauley929

      cpauley929 

      Can't waid to read 1602. Gaiman is such a genius. I'll read anything and everything he creates, which puts the Sandman as number one of my most favorite graphic novels.
      posted 3 weeks ago. ( reply )
  • Nicholas H

    Nicholas H 

    1. P Craig Russell's Ring of the Nibelung
    This is a two volume gem that rekindled my love of the graphic novel.

    2. John Constantine: Hellblazer
    I'm a fan of the horror genre, and this is the best horror comic I've read in years.

    3. Batman: The Long Halloween
    I usually don't like DC, but this had some excellent storytelling, and the art was amazing. It read like a noir film, without the Milleresque confusion of Sin City.
    posted 7 months ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • Seeker of Truth

      Seeker of Truth 

      Jack Kirby - Conan and Elric of Melnibone
      The Death of Superman
      Hellboy
      posted 7 months ago. ( reply )
  • Sharifa F

    Sharifa F 

    Since Watchmen goes in my category of top books everyone should read, I'll leave it out even though it's kind of cheating.
    1. From Hell
    2. Maus
    3. Persepolis
    I wish I could be more original, but the greats are the greats.
    posted 6 months ago. ( reply )
  • Joe Girard

    Joe Girard 

    Stand alones: Fun Home, Blankets, I Killed Adolf Hitler
    Series: Bone, Usagi Yojimbo, Sin City
    Anthologies: Flight, The Best American Graphic Novels Series, The Push Man and Other Stories
    Manga: Akira, Death Note, Genshiken

    Honourable Mentions: My New York Diary, Y, Stuck Rubber Baby, In Me Own Words, Maus, Sticks and Stones, Same Difference and other Stories, Tricked, 300, Sloth, White Rapids, the Paul series, Sandman, the Graphic History of the Universe series, and so on

    This list will just grow and grow. My top three lists are based on one criteria: that the work in question left a durable impact on my life. I bore through a few novels a week, and a lot of them are so painfully forgettable. Painful, when you consider what could have been for the talent involved.
    posted 6 months ago. ( reply )
  • Jeff Buehler

    Jeff Buehler 

    I have to go with:

    1. Okko - The Cycler of Water (so far)
    2. The Incal Books 1 and 2 (Moebius)
    3. 30 Days Of Night

    Sandman, The Artesia Series, Pride Of Baghdad, Gaimans Stardust and The Eternals, Marvels 1602, Batman - The Dark Knight and Frank Millers stuff, and others occasionally enter and leave my top 3 list ...
    posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • Keyblader Erika

      Keyblader Erika 

      OO thats a toughy here are mine
      1. Spider man: The legend begins
      2. X-men Pheniox's revenge
      3. BAtman A gotham Halloween
      posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
  • kevin c

    kevin c 

    A lot of people don't read comic books so I try to let them read the ones with characters that are familiar to them. It makes them crave for more, and that's when I lend them books from Alan Moore and other must-haves.
    Here are my picks for "everyone" else:
    1) Identity Crisis
    2) Batman: Long Halloween
    3) Superman: Red Son

    I'm a die-hard DC fan, so I won't recommend any Marvel titles. :P
    posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
    show 2 replies
    • VM

      VM 

      Top is The Lone Wolf and Cub series.
      posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
    • Keyblader Erika

      Keyblader Erika 

      i stick with mine
      posted 5 months ago. ( reply )
  • jared  h

    jared h 

    1: hellboy
    2: hellblazer
    3: v for vendetta
    posted 4 months ago. ( reply )
  • KD

    KD 

    Hmm....

    1. Maus
    2. Watchmen
    3. Persepolis


    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
    show 2 replies
    • Pete W

      Pete W 

      apart from the obvious three (watchmen, dark knight returns, sandman):

      1. Wanted
      2. WE3
      3. Earth X
      posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
    • Dipan B

      Dipan B 

      I read Persepolis and I loved it. Am glad someone brought it into this forum. I do believe comic series should be separate from graphic novels like Maus and Persepolis. These are, IMHO, different genres. Haven't read watchmen or v for vendetta - but now I think I will give them a try.
      posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • terry

    terry (edited)

    one-shots:
    watchmen
    v for vendetta
    blankets

    series:
    the walking dead
    preacher
    sandman
    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • Shamin C

    Shamin C 

    1. Watchmen
    2. Fell by Warren Ellis
    3. Transmetropolitan
    posted 3 months ago. ( reply )
  • hope i

    hope i 

    If you love graphic novels as much as you all do then I know many of you have probably already read a book by one of the all-time great comics theorist, Scott McCloud. He wrote Understanding Comics and others sucha s Reinventing Comics and Making Comics but Understanding Comics is my favorite. It really turns the medium on its head whether you are a reader or a writer of the medium. If you get a chance read the collection of the first fiction he ever wrote in graphic novel form called Zot! 1987-1991. It just came out in paperback and as it turns out this series is where he first began testing his theories about comics. It also happened to change the graphic novel world in its day-- it was a true precursor to American Manga as he was seriously influenced by many Japanese artists unknown here in the states at the time. Very cool stuff. Enjoy
    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • Brother A

    Brother A 

    3 Graphic Novels that everyone should read:

    Watchmen - Alan Moore
    Nat Turner - Kyle Baker
    Books of Magic - Neil Gaiman

    3 series that everyone should read

    Miracle Man - Alan Moore
    Sandman - Neil Gaiman
    Death Note - Tsugumi Ohba and Takeshi Obata
    posted 2 months ago. ( reply )
  • Holli G

    Holli G 

    1. A Contract with God by Will Eisner
    I'm surprised more people haven't posted this. It really is an integral part of comics history in America as well as a vignette of American life in the 1930s. The plot behind the stories are timeless. The sequential story-telling is unmatched in all of Eisner's work which is why its used in many sequential art classes to demonstrate how to manipulate a readers response and move a story forward.

    2. The Watchmen by Alan Moore
    This is just modern comics at its best. Alan moore is an excellent writer, Gibbons and Higgins completed the team as penciller/inker and colorist. It took the idea of the 'masked adventurer' and 'super hero' and placed them in a much more realistic, if not cynical world. Its an excellent satire on hero comics and also uses the comic book medium to tell a really great intellectual story.

    3. JLA Grant Morrison run
    Morrison did great things with classic super heros. These stories were fun and well written.
    posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
  • Jen C

    Jen C 

    I just found this group - awesome!! But this is SO hard - which makes it fun :).

    In no order, cuz I'm not that masochistic:

    * The Compleat Moonshadow
    * Jimmy Corrigan - Smartest Kid on Earth
    * V for Vendetta
    * Bone

    That was 4? No, of course not :P. But there are so many others...
    posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
  • neuba

    neuba 

    Although I haven't read a whole lot, I would have to say:
    1. Sandman
    2. Fables
    3. Walking Dead
    posted 3 weeks ago. ( reply )
  • cpauley929

    cpauley929 

    Because I'm being limited to three they are as follows:

    1.) The Sandman - maybe typical, but Gaiman is my hero

    2.) Midnight Nation - it was actually a mini series, and maybe the reason I love it so much is that it reminds me of Neverwhere by (again) Gaiman. this comic is J. Michael Straczynski.

    3.) Fables - I love fairy tales so this was a natural fit for me.

    Honorable mention to:
    Johnny the Homicidal Maniac
    posted 3 weeks ago. ( reply )
  • Ruby.Zero

    Ruby.Zero 

    Hell and Back ( A Sin City Love Story)
    The Death of Captain America (I like the converstaion between Wolverine and Spider-man, to me it conveyed the most realistic feeling of lost)
    Young Avengers
    posted 2 weeks ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • Domhnall

      Domhnall 

      ...Steampunk vol.1 and 2
      By Chris Bachalo, my fave artist.

      ...House Of M
      Wolverine gets his memory back, Scarlet Witch comes off the side line and shows how powerfull she really is.

      ...Ascend
      By Keith Arem, check it out.
      posted 2 weeks ago. ( reply )
  • Frank S

    Frank S 

    1. Strangers in Paradise - Terry Moore
    2. Preacher - Warren Ellis
    3. Sandman, of course,
    4. The Pro - Warren Ellis
    5. Whiteout - Greg Rucka

    but wait... there's more....
    Preacher, Contract With God and anything Eisner did, all the Sin City's, Watchmen, Miracle Man (Moore's), Bone, The Ultimate Avengers (Joss Wheadon)....

    but wait... there's more....(to come)
    posted 9 days ago. ( reply )
  • To reply to this discussion, please sign in or join now.

Return to top
© 2008 Tastemakers, Inc. | Portions of Shelfari.com are Copyright © 1996-2008 Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates. Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy | Copyright Policy