Books
Group avatar

Science Fiction

Science fiction includes such a wide range of themes and sub-genres that it is notoriously difficult to define. This is a list of definitions that have been offered by authors, editors, critics and fans over the years since science fiction became clearly separate from other genres. Definitions of related terms such as "science fantasy",...more »
  • Category: Genres | Started February 2007

« more discussions

  • mark s

    Anyone notice the similariities between these 3 works?

    Number of the Beast (Heinlien), Paul Anderson's "Avatar", and Peirs Anthony's "Race against Time"
    mark s started this discussion 1 month ago. ( reply )

13

replies
expand replies 
Sign in to participate in this discussion.
  • euicho

    euicho 

    I havn't read Avatar but I've been meaning to. I'll have to do so and compare it to Number of the Beast. I've not read Race against time either :(

    posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
  • Dog Lover

    Dog Lover 

    OTP:

    Mark - is that Wolfman Jack as your new avatar? I'm revealing my age by asking the question, I guess.

    Whattaguy!

    DL

    (I'll fall back on the "age" thing as an excuse, if it isn't WJ.)

    posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • mark s

      mark s 

      Yes it is:D I figured it being near Halloween and all:D

      Good job! See he still lives on!

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
  • Nee

    Nee 

    It's been a long time since I’ve read those, but as I recall they are all quite different in style and delivery. what...are saying that there are elements that are the same, or that they all are on similar topics?

    posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • mark s

      mark s 

      That they approach time/space in a similar manner.

      posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
  • Nee

    Nee 

    Hmmm...now you are making me wonder if I am approaching the subject in a similar way as they did in my space/time story. I do know however, I am using theme in slightly different ways, and emphasizing certain aspects they did not.

    But then, there are only so many ways to look at a particular subject.

    posted 1 month ago. ( reply )
    show 1 reply
    • mark s

      mark s 

      there are many ways to look at time travel, it is odd however how they start to blur into faster than light theory...l

      posted 4 weeks ago. ( reply )
  • Mark W. Tiedemann

    Mark W. Tiedemann 

    Sorry, can't say I see any similarities between the Heinlein and the Anderson. Haven't read the Anthony, but then I gave up on him with the Bio of a Space Tyrant series.

    posted 8 days ago. ( reply )
    show 4 replies
    • mark s

      mark s (edited)

      What didn't you care for in Bio?

      posted 7 days ago. ( reply )
    • Mark W. Tiedemann

      Mark W. Tiedemann 

      By that time it was a combination of burn out (I had read just about everything he put out up to that point) and the fact that he was shamelessly employing some of the cheesiest cliches of melodrama and not even trying to hide the fact. Every third or fourth page I had an "Aw, come on!" reaction and when the refugees started singing "Joe Hill" I'd had it.

      posted 2 days ago. ( reply )
    • mark s

      mark s 

      hmmm...okay. I kinda thought the books were written as propaganda from the tyrant's perspective...maybe I read too much into it.

      posted 2 days ago. ( reply )
    • Mark W. Tiedemann

      Mark W. Tiedemann 

      No, you may be correct. It just didn't work as such for me.

      posted 2 days ago. ( reply )
  • Chip M

    Chip M (edited)

    Not read Avatar, but when I saw the trailer for James Cameron's film from it, I immediately thought "The Integral Trees". Probably are no where related but the creatures and their world struck me as similar.

    posted 4 days ago. ( reply )
  • To reply to this discussion, please sign in or join now.

Return to top