Ancient History Book
Reviewed by
an Amazon user,
March 24, 2007
This book contains much "big picture" information that I already knew, but there are many smaller details and facts that I did not know prior. Although only about halfway through, I can state that imo the author knows his field, writes smoothly, does not go overboard with minutiae, and conveys a sense of presence during those ancient times. It is ancient history that has corrected some of the impressions that I have gained through historical fiction - which I will also continue to read.
|
Caesar: His Life and Times
Reviewed by
an Amazon user,
March 20, 2007
This is the second book by Adrian Goldsworthy that I've read and once again he does not disappoint. This is a substantial biography on one of the most established figures in history. Established in the sense that people have heard the name and for the connotations the name brings forth to different people, even if they (we) have not really studied that much about Caius Julius Caesar. Goldsworthy is an excellent historian on Roman history, particularly on the military and political aspects of that once powerful city and its empire.
I'm not going to recite Julius Caesar's life journey in detail, read the book for that. This is a very well-rounded and complete (as far as is probably possible) portrait of the man and the times he lived in, from his youth to his death at the hands of the conspirators in 44 BC. Regardless of what impressions you have or final judgements you make, and I agree with Goldsworthy's conclusion in that most people will probably have a mixed opinion, you can't deny his extraordinary abilities, especially in the military sphere. It was absolutely astonishing to read of the staggering casualties his army inflicted on all his various opponents from the Gallic War to the Civil War and the comparatively minor casualties his army incurred. However, these numbers, as the author mentioned, could easily be exaggerated. Caesar made mistakes, but boy did he win and win big, time after time.
But in addition to his famed military prowess, Caesar was a shrewd politician. What Goldsworthy likes to stress throughout this book is that Caesar, compared to other dictators and leaders was known for his clemency. Of course this could have all been purely for calculated political purposes, but nevertheless, those who opposed Caesar fared better than say those who opposed Sulla in the previous Civil War. This is a fair point, but does not skew the fact that he could be ruthless in times of war, but as Goldsworthy believes, even that ruthlessness was not necessarily for cruelty's sake. The author is certainly trying to put Caesar in a somewhat sympathetic or more favorable light than others might, but he also admirably places Caesar within the context of the times he lived in.
This biography isn't as purely focused on Caesar as some might assume it would be. Goldsworthy gives a fair amount of attention to Roman political life in this age as well, which is necessary. The turbulent times in Roman history that transpired throughout Julius Caesar's life, who some of the other players were, the changing dynamics of Roman society, and so forth are all incorporated into this fascinating and well written book. Whatever conclusions one may reach about Caesar or Roman life and its politics in general, you surely can't deny the impact this conspicuous Roman had and how that legacy continues to fascinate us today, though we are so far removed in time from that turbulent and dramatic age. There is much we don't learn in this book and most likely will never know, which is probably another reason why many people, including myself, are drawn to this period in history. A commendable book by an eminent historian and writer.
|
One of the First Great Men
Reviewed by
an Amazon user,
March 13, 2007
Adrian Goldsworthy gives us an important examination of the one of the earlier men that 19th Century historians labelled "great men." And, as the author shows, this was a man of extraordinary ambition, political skill, and ruthlessness. He was not a man of "vision" (in the modern sense of that word), but he was the master politician. One of the pleasing things about this book is the author is frank to say what we know and don't know, what we can guess was going on, and what it is probably unsafe to assume. One result is that we come away with a very honest, detailed, and interesting view of Roman politics and society at the end of the Republic.
|
A vastly entertaining read!
Reviewed by
an Amazon user,
March 5, 2007
I had read Goldsworthy's "In The Name Of Rome" previously on a business trip and couldn't put it down. The same goes for "Caesar: Life of a Colossus". It's a fast and entertaining read. One thing Goldsworthy excels at is saying a lot with only a few words. He is one of those rare historians that can communicate his points and concepts in a very fluid and enjoyable way. Sometimes his writing can be profound and almost poetic. Here are some of my favorites from "Caesar: Life of a Colossus":
"It is common for those who flourish under any system to feel the failure of others is deserved."
"There was a remarkable elasticity in the main institutions of the Republic, which tended to continue running in some form under almost any circumstances, interrupted only temporarily by riot and bloodshed."
There are many more gems just like these scattered throughout the book. I highly recommend it.
|
Brings the Marble Man to Life
Reviewed by
an Amazon user,
March 2, 2007
Goldsworthy's Caesar is an extraordinarily well-written one-volume biography. Some who have sniffed that Goldsworthy's treatment is not comprehensive enough miss the point - this is supposed to be a one-volume biography of Caesar and the book is 519 pages as is without chasing after the disputes between Crassus and Pompey. The author shows remarkable discipline in not wandering off down the many enticing pathways offered by the late Roman Republic. Goldsworthy specifically cautioned at the beginning that he intends to stay focused on Caesar and Caesar alone and that is what he does.
Writing a biography of Caesar presents the formidable challenge of humanizing the subject - much like writing about Napoleon or Robert E. Lee. They are the 'marble men' in Shelby Foote's phrasing. Goldsworthy succeeds admirably in this regard. He repeatedly cautions the reader not to regard the events of Caesar's life as inevitable. The reader gets the sense of Caesar as a man who strove to succeed above all else, but could have failed.
His lively writing style paints an engaging portrait of Caesar (much more so than Anthony Everritt's 'Augustus', for example). Crisply described battle scenes give the reader a good sense of what happened and why, whether against the Gauls at Alesia or Pompey at Pharsalus.
Contrary to some other reviewers, I found that Goldsworthy's background as a preeminent military historian serves him well. At Caesar's most successful he was above all a Roman general and spent most of the last 15 years of his life fighting wars first against Rome's enemies and later against other Romans. True, Caesar was nearly 40 before he embarked on the victories that made his place in history, but we remember him for those years as a military leader not for his role as praetor or pontifex maximus.
A remarkable one-volume biography. I'd give it more than 5 stars if I could. Highest recommendation.
|