Russian Debutante's Handbook
 

Russian Debutante's Handbook

by Gary Shteyngart

This is the story of Vladimir Girshkin-part P.T. Barnum, part V.I. Lenin, the man who would conquer half of Europe (albeit the wrong half). (read review)

Top tags: fictioncontemporary fictionrussiarussianrussian fiction (all tags)

Overview: Amazon Reviews

Funny and clever but drags on
  • Rated 3 stars
Reviewed by an Amazon user, 2008-10-11
As a Russian immigrant (he came to US when he was 7), Shteyngart writes about what he knows and it shows in his books. He is an excellent writer. Like his subsequent novel, Absurdistan, Russian Debutante's Handbook will deliver if it is humor, satire, and amusing prose you are after. If you do not mind reading the same type of genre and style then I would recommend both of his books. However, after Absurdistan I found certain aspects of this novel got tedious and by the end I was happy that it was over. Shteyngart's strength is his humor and original writing style. His bizarre plot and final chase scene became too much like a cheap Hollywood movie. Nevertheless I recommend reading at least one of his two books.
Writer should write more than pretty sentences
  • Rated 1 stars
Reviewed by an Amazon user, 2008-10-08
The author clearly has a talent with language, there are many cleverly written passages in the book - and these are sometimes quite amusing. I wanted to like this book, but am putting it down at about 275 pages into it. The main character gives me no reason to care what he will do next. The catalog of characters are caricature comments on cultural (not just ethnic but class and attitude) stereotypes that wear out their initial delivery of comical observation. Perhaps this book is just too long for what it is. I liked - not loved - Absurdistan, and I found this novel to be more heavily inflicted with the problems of that book. Sorry, I tried, just couldn't care enough to finish it.
dazzling
  • Rated 4 stars
Reviewed by an Amazon user, 2008-05-17
I am glad to see the term "picaresque" applied to this novel, for it truly belongs within that genre. But while the story bounds along, at times verging on the highly improbable, the language dazzles on every page - in every paragraph, in fact. The author, to whom English was (I imagine) a 2nd or 3rd language, shares with Joseph Conrad (and not a few other non-native English speakers) an enviable mastery of the most subtle wit, the choicest use of epithets, the snappiest of similes. And, having spent a bit of time in Tbilisi, Georgia, in the past decade, I thought more than once or twice in the course of my reading how well that valley city, with its river, smog - and wall-to-wall gangsters - could have served as the setting of this unlikely but likeable tale...
Choppy, original, and, hilarious.
  • Rated 4 stars
Reviewed by an Amazon user, 2008-03-26
Choppy and broken plot line reads like broken English (as intended). Hilarity ensues on every page. Page-turner start to finish. Russian debutantes never make appearance.
Stretching belief
  • Rated 3 stars
Reviewed by an Amazon user, 2008-02-06
The principle character, Vladimir, is basically a non-descript Russian immigrant nebbish, in his mid-twenties, who has a dead end job (in an immigration absorption office) in Manhattan, an overbearing mother (hence the comparisons to Philip Roth's "Portnoy's Complaint") and a chubby girlfriend who works as a dominant/submissive. Like so many others his age, Vladimir is looking for a boost in his life, and gets it both by dating Francisca, the ultimate shiksa (unrealistically, he moves in with her and her family) and by meeting the criminally connected Rybakov, a crazy old Russian, desperate for U.S. citizenship. He gets mixed up with a mafioso figure in Florida, and, with the help of Rybakov, flees to the fictitious bleak Eastern European City of "Prava" (nothing like Prague at all, which is one of the most beautiful cities in the world) where he joins a mafioso gang headed by Rybakov's son. Surprisingly to me, Vladimir quickly rises as a result of a Ponzi scheme in which he attempts to rip off young American expatriates. This former schlemiel mama's boy apparently has the capacity to completely change his personality.

While I could appreciate the author's formidable writing skills and obvious ability to spin a good humorous yarn, ulitimately, the book didn't really work for me. In short, I didn't buy a number of the characters, but especially Vladimir. The plot (and even some of the stylistic writing) often felt quite forced to me, especially when Vladimir establishes himself so quickly in Prava demonstrating the confidence of a hard core scam artist. Of course, he also has the ability to easily win over the most desirable woman around, even though he isn't particularly attractive or clever. The ending, for anyone looking for any semblance of rationality, is completely absurd.

Nevertheless, I'm going to keep my eye on this author. I'll probably read "Absurdistan" at some point -- just not right away.
© 2008 Shelfari, Inc. | Portions of Shelfari.com are Copyright © 1996-2008 Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates. Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy | Copyright Policy