Books

Niccimae C
1 of 1 members found this review helpful.
  • Rated 2 stars

I was given this book as a gift from someone (an Aussie) who had read it and knowing of my deep desire to see India thought I would enjoy it. While it is certainly not what one would deem informative travel literature it does paint a picture, a really nasty, messy, disgusting one. So yes, India is dirty, not hard to imagine a country of that size with that many people and such bad infrastructure as being filthy. India is full of seemingly childish, irresponsible people who can't find their way anywhere and just want to take your money, way to be objective and tell a non fictional account!

I rarely if ever felt that the author even remotely enjoyed one minute of being in such a wondrous, thought provoking place. It was just endless complaining about the noise, the heat, the squalor, the people. Even when supposedly enjoying herself, she snuck in little barbs about the country. All the so called humor tended to be at the expense of Indians, a people with very little who were always willing to share and help her when they could. In the end this book is just another "selfish, bourgeois western agnostic, searches for God in the crazy whirligig of MAD, DIRTY India!"

This is not something I would recommend for those travelling to India, unless they just want to be scared off their trip.

Niccimae C wrote this review Monday, June 1 2009. ( reply | view 2 replies | permalink )
  • Chaitra

    chaitra said:

    I totally agree and would like to add that the author is in no way less melodramatic in all her complaints and suposed experiences of spirituality than she claims the Indians are. No wonder she was so warmly welcomed by all the Indian families she met as they saw a little(lot) of them in her!!!

    posted Thursday, June 18 2009
  • prasadvidhata

    prasadvidhata said:

    I perfectly agree with you. India is not such a bad place after all. Some books are based on the little they saw in India. Any way, I have just started reading this book. Let me find out how bad a picture of India this book manages to cut. But this is dfinitly not a book to be recommended to tourists. For, they might find an entirely different India and people on their arrival here.

    posted Thursday, July 16 2009 ( | view 1 reply )
Advertisement