Books

  • Lilly  B

    lilly b said:

    I loved how there was a happy ending because that is what i wanted the whole time. Would you have been happy if Bella or Edward died? I would of been depressed, people described like this need a happy ending. I would of been so upset if the story ended with jacob and Renesmee escaping and all the rest of the Cullen family dieing. Is that what you wanted to happen ? am not saying it is bad what you said just to clear that up.

    posted Monday, August 11 2008 ( | view 2 replies )
  • Rachel S

    rachel s said:

    Actually, I would have preferred if Edward and Bella died, but that's just me. They are badly written characters. I wouldn't have missed them.

    posted Sunday, August 24 2008
  • Erin F

    erin f said:

    I don't want Bella or Edward to die. However I would have liked Alec and Jane to die and some other various characters. She could have left the Cullen family alone and kept them living but picked off some other good guys and a lot of the bad guys.

    posted Monday, November 10 2008