The Anatomy of Deception
 

The Anatomy of Deception

by Lawrence Goldstone

A mesmerizing forensic thriller that thrusts the reader into the operating rooms, drawing rooms, and back alleys of 1889 Philadelphia, as a young doctor grapples with the principles of scientific process to track a daring killer

In the morgue of a Philadelphia hospital, a group of physicians open a coffin and uncover the corpse of a beautiful young woman. What they see takes their... (read more)

Top tags: historical fiction19th centurymedicinefictionmystery (all tags)

 

Member Reviews

  • Colleen S
    • Rated 4 stars

    I sometimes had trouble staying with the book but in general I found it to be a fascinating look at autopsies and the practice of medicine in the late 19th Century.

    Colleen S wrote this review Wednesday, June 25 2008. ( reply | permalink )
  • Play Book Tag Shelf
    • Rated 4 stars

    A new forensic thriller that takes place in 1889 Philadelphia. Dr. Ephraim Carrol came to Philadelphia to study with a leading professor, the brilliant William Osler. Medicine is changing rapidly, surgery is becoming cleaner. But Carrol and his mentor are at odds over what they glimpsed one morning in the hospital's Dead House. Then a second mysterious death is determined to have been a ruthless murder. The story is interspersed with references to real people and places. An interesting read.

    Play Book Tag Shelf wrote this review Sunday, May 4 2008. ( reply | permalink )
  • punxsygal
    • Rated 5 stars

    Reading this book makes you appreciate the cleanliness of modern medicine. A dark mystery into the disappearance of a young woman and the poisoning of young doctor. It describes life in 19th century Philadelphia and discusses plans for the new modern hospital in Baltimore, John Hopkins.

    punxsygal wrote this review Sunday, May 4 2008. ( reply | permalink )
  • jenlaw77
    • Rated 4 stars

    Dr. Ephraim Carroll comes to the University Of Pennsylvania Medical School to study under the renowned Dr. William Osler. He is soon pulled into an investigation of a chain of murders that seemed to be tied to the doctors of the medical school. The murders introduce Ephraim to both the high society and underbelly of Philadelphia. Ephraim must decide what is more important, the life of one man, or the well-being of thousands. This is an amazing forensic thriller that will draw in the reader instantly. This book is filled with mystery, intrigue, and a historical account of medical practices in 1889.

    jenlaw77 wrote this review Monday, April 14 2008. ( reply | permalink )
  • Jacqueline H
    • Rated 3 stars

    Entertaining and well-researched historical mystery set in 1889 Philadelphia's medical and art circles. Because I live near Philly, I particularly appreciated the local color and characters such as Thomas Eakins. I also liked the unexpectedly realistic ending, which was a nice change of pace for a regular mystery reader like me.

    Jacqueline H wrote this review Monday, March 17 2008. ( reply | permalink )
  • Isabelle S
    • Rated 3 stars

    I'm of two brains about this one, as a friend of mine would say. First, I think Goldstone did an outstanding job of situating his book at such at that he could convey a tremendous amount of information about medical history without resorting (with a few exceptions) to straight lecture. By choosing a time period where innovations such as gloves, sterile surgeries and even clamps were still debated, he could work in lots of fascinating material.

    On the other hand, all that fascinating material made the plot plod a bit, and I never had a good feel for Ephraim- someone so smart shouldn't have been so gullible and his character wasn't consistent enough (to me) to predict how he'd act in any given instance. I confess I also have a few qualms about the license taken with the actual historical characters. Still, I'd definitely recommend it to anyone mildly interested in medical history. (and I defy anyone tp read it without googling Eakins' portraits.)

    I disagree with Carrie's review, below, that there was preaching on morality. If anything, the story shows morality in flux - there's a continuum from the reverend's conviction that it's immoral to do autopsies to the "free love" society surrounding Eakins, with a stop off at the settlement in between. I thought it was a good portrayal of the time period.

    Isabelle S wrote this review Friday, March 7 2008. ( reply | permalink )
  • carrie c
    • Rated 3 stars

    Although I could not put this book down, I don't trust what feels like a good bit of preaching on morality and medicine. Perhaps Goldstone simply stuck to portraying the morays of the time, but I find it suspect that anyone who veered off the beaten morality path came out looking rather awful. //PUBLISHER REVIEW--A mesmerizing forensic thriller that thrusts the reader into the operating rooms, drawing rooms, and back alleys of 1889 Philadelphia, as a young doctor grapples with the principles of scientific process to track a daring killer In the morgue of a Philadelphia hospital, a group of physicians open a coffin and uncover the corpse of a beautiful young woman. What they see takes their breath away. Within days, one of them strongly suspects that he knows the woman’s identity…and the horrifying events that led to her death. But in this richly atmospheric novel–an ingenious blend of history, suspense and early forensic science–the most compelling chapter is yet to come, as young Ephraim Carroll is plunged into a maze of murder, secrets and unimaginable crimes.... Dr. Ephraim Carroll came to Philadelphia to study with a leading professor, the brilliant William Osler, believing that he would gain the power to save countless lives. As America hurtles toward a new century, medicine is changing rapidly, in part due to the legalization of autopsy–a crime only a few years before. But Carroll and his mentor are at odds over what they glimpsed that morning in the hospital’s Dead House. And when a second mysterious death is determined to have been a ruthless murder, Carroll can feel the darkness gathering around him–and he ignites an investigation of his own. Soon he is moving between the realm of elite medicine, Philadelphia high society, and a teeming badlands of criminality and sexual depravity along the city’s fetid waterfront. With a wealthy, seductive woman clouding his vision, the controversial artist Thomas Eakins sowing scandal, and the secrets of the nation’s powerful surgeons unraveling around him, Carroll is forced to confront an agonizing moral choice–between exposing a killer, undoing a wrong, and, quite possibly, protecting the future of medicine itself….

    carrie c wrote this review Monday, February 11 2008. ( reply | permalink )
  • Rowan sees children eager to learn, not colors
    • Rated 5 stars

    I have a pre-release copy of this book and it is well worth the read if you are into forensics. This book includes some charecters that are the fathers of modern medicine and forensics. I personally love this tale for it's historical flare. A decent read for a cold night.

    Rowan sees children eager to learn, not colors wrote this review Thursday, January 24 2008. ( reply | permalink )
© 2008 Tastemakers, Inc. | Portions of Shelfari.com are Copyright © 1996-2008 Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates. Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy | Copyright Policy