Books

LoneB
19 of 22 members found this review helpful.
  • Rated 2 stars

I am largely disappointed with this book, especially given all the hype surrounding it. The self talk that is detailed ad noseum throughout the first half of the book is truly painful. And her redefinition of religion to be simply whatever makes one happy is flippantly dismissive of 5000+ years of contemplative religious scholarship and reflection, which seems shallow and a bit arrogant. Not to mention her having no problem meditating on herself despite being in a country where some of the most oppressed women in the world live a life of abject suffering every day. I cant help but feel like her spiritual choices were nothing more than a response to years under the microcope of over-achievement and self un-awareness in America. Once she got to Bali, and met the Balinese divorcee, I was waiting for that jail-cell moment in Bridget Jones II, where after hearing her new friend’s truly horrendous story of spousal beatings and degridation she would realize that perhaps her relationships had'nt been that bad after all. But it never happened. I did love her descriptions of the places she visited, though. The soccer match in Italy, the garden at dusk in India, and her hilarious road trip in Bali. I love poor Yudhi. And the description of the cottage she rented in Bali made me salivate with envy. And of course, so did the trysts with the Latin Lover. Not until the end of the book did I begin to appreciate what she may or may not have been trying to say. In her grief and desperation she befriended people all over the world, even taking seriously the medicine man in Bali whose contradictory ideas of reality exposed his lonliness and senility. She took the time. And that human interaction, reaching out to all those random people, caring about their story and their lives, was healing to her and to them. And thats what I love. But it was a whole lot of drama and eye rolling getting there.

LoneB wrote this review Saturday, March 29 2008. ( reply | view 10 replies | permalink )
  • Benjamin O

    benjamin o said:

    You made it further than I was willing to subject myself. Her somewhat clever asides wore quickly and I felt like I was trapped in an endless lunch date with a friend who only interacts so she can talk about herself and where every question she asks is a really a thinly veiled opportunity to talk yet more about herself. I will put it on my shelf and see if I can pick it back up in the near future to see if I can gain the insight that so many seemed to gleam from the book.

    posted Monday, July 14 2008 ( | view 3 replies )
  • MJ B

    mj b said:

    I agree. Her writing style moves in slow motion or in a circle around herself. I only made it to Italy and considered picking it up again...but I've decided not to. I know where to find good travel writing. I think the book is a case of good marketing.

    posted Thursday, July 31 2008
  • crissie said:

    I read this book during a time of move, a time when there is always plenty of drama, like it or not. For one who can do without drama in my own life and have a difficult time with created drama in others' lives, I found hers rather refreshing. The pace of the book was right for me, easy going, no rushing. She definitely was focused on herself, but then wasn't that the reason for the travelling, her need to find herself and heal? and that is what she wrote. Having had difficulty with failure in the past and having learned to get over myself and enjoy something new, knowing I will not be as good as someone who has spent years at it (book arts, for example), I found it refreshing to read about Gilbert's failures and her ability to come out on the bright side of life. She put her failures out there but in no way do they diminish her as a human being.

    posted Thursday, July 31 2008
  • Dalee

    dalee said:

    personally not only enjoyed this book but found myself inspired by it. I have to say that I don't think it's fair to judge the book based on the authors personal spiritual practices. It says right in the title that this is about one woman's search, it's not meant to be a religious studies manual or even a how-to find you own spiritual enlightenment guide. I was not bothered at all that she had "no problem meditating on herself despite being in a country where some of the most oppressed women in the world live a life of abject suffering every day." She was in said countries not as a good will ambassador but because she was on an internal journey which is by its very nature a self focused time in a persons life. I am a person who has that 'I must save the world' mentality and one of the hardest lessons for me is one that my mother has been repeating to me for many years now and that's that you have to take care of yourself and your immediate family before you can take care of the entire world. I feel that during the writing of this book, the author was in a place of nurturing her own spirit and in essence saving herself. If that seams selfish, well then I pity those who can't see through their own glass house to see how very necessary this type of journey is to every person.

    posted Sunday, August 3 2008
  • cagrowngirl

    cagrowngirl said:

    you made it a lot further than i did. but it was the only book that i didn't finish in 13 weeks. i read 100. i couldn't make it out of italy. who the heck is depressed in italy of all places. she mentioned medication. she should bite the bullet and just take it. my mother-in-law recommended the book to me. one of my best gf said no---don't read it. i should of listened to the gf.

    posted Wednesday, August 6 2008
  • clementine

    clementine said:

    I'm glad to see I'm not alone in detesting the ego-centric blather that largely makes up this book.

    posted Friday, September 5 2008 ( | view 1 reply )
  • Susan K

    susan k said:

    ad nauseum...

    posted Saturday, September 6 2008 ( | view 1 reply )
  • Geordi L

    geordi l said:

    LoneB's review was right on. A Sex in the City guide to enlightenment - like OMG!

    posted Thursday, September 18 2008 ( | view 1 reply )
  • WIND

    wind said:

    so many words so bad comments and so obvious that you envy so much this woman and the way she dared to llive her life!

    posted Sunday, September 28 2008 ( | view 2 replies )
  • Walter M

    walter m said:

    LOL. I found the stuff about her failed marriage a little embarrassing too, but I thought it was just a guy thing. I'm glad you stuck with it, though. You have to admit she's pretty brave to put so much of herself out there. I take your point about religion, but at the end of the day I think that maybe 99% of authentic believers and followers ARE in it for personal happiness and contentment. I think most non-religious Western people have a tendency to over-intellectualize the religious experience. I also think that that's maybe why the book was so successful - she was actually giving voice to an honest experience. I agree, it's extremely patchy, and even silly in parts - but the overall experience is quite interesting, and since I read it over a year ago I have found myself engaged in discussions with all sorts of people about it, so I think it's one of those "must-reads." Anyway, just wanted to say I loved your review.

    posted Wednesday, June 17 2009
Advertisement