kristin c says

I find it /so/ interesting that you are Team Edward, but hate Jared! I don't know, Edward and Jared were very parallel for me. Mostly because Ian was such a total opposite from Jared. Just like Jake was a total opposite of Edward. Ian and Wanda's relationship came to be through friendship while Wanderer and Jared's came to be in a more swept up in the romance kind of way like the Edward/Bella relationship. So, I'm interested that you don't like Jared. I love how these books get us all twisty/turvy.

posted 18 hours ago

(This is a response to a previous comment)

(read kristin c’ review)

sydney says

i agree with "sam t." Jered is really awefull! i think he just ruins the story! oh well! it was an amazing book anyway!!! im reading for a third time!

posted 1 day ago

dazzling says

I'm also reading it. I'm being a little critical and testy, since it's my first time reading Meyer's book. But so far, it definitely hooked me in.

posted 1 day ago

sam t says

I'm reading it now, and I'm on page 200, and so far, I love the book! (I really hate Jered though...) I don't know what happens in the end... but I'm reading it like a maniac to find out!

posted 1 day ago

*haley* says

I liked the book very much and I would recommend this book to anyone. In the beginning I did not know if I liked it because it talked about souls but in the end I loved it and I hope there are more coming out. She is a great writer and I have read all her books . I was very sad at the end when wanda got her own body because I felt like she wasa part of Melanie and that leaving her is like leaving herself like she is not her self anymore but a different (person)/soal. But other than that I really enjoyed this book and would recommend it to anyone:)

posted 4 days ago

(read *haley*’ review)

abby r says

I loved this book so much! It was just great and I would recommend it to anyone. I would much rather to have seen it end with more finality rather than have the story be stretched into a trilogy.

posted 6 days ago

kristin c says

I went into this book with a very crticial eye. I only read this to see if Meyer had improved at all in her writing from the Twilight series (which I enjoy). And she had! But that didn't even matter because Meyer sucked me into her world from the very beginning.

I loved this book. I was sad it ended. Though, it appears based on comments typed here that it is a trilogy in the works? That sounds like fun to me!

I had very mixed feelings about the ending, but I still love the book.

I find it interesting that so many comments were directed at the "sexual tension" that bothered the reader because they knew Meyer doesn't write sex scenes. I have to say, I was so caught up in the relationships between the characters that I certainly wasn't thinking, "What this book is misssing is a good ol' roll in the hay!" It was so much more interesting to watch the characters interact with each other in other ways.

I love this book, and will definitely be adding it to my Meyer collection when it comes out in paperback.

posted 6 days ago

(read kristin c’ review)

zoe w says

If you are a fan of the Twilight series you definetly have to read this book! I love it! Stephenie Meyer is a totally great author... I can't wait to see what new book/series she'll come up with!

posted 8 days ago

(read zoe w’ review)

tonya t says

This was a great book. I was a little skeptical at first, but once I got into, I really enjoyed it.

posted 8 days ago

(read tonya t’ review)