Members with This Book
Most Helpful Reviews
see all reviews
Liked It “I'd loved two of Hope Tarr's earlier historicals--My Lord Jack and Tempting, but forgot to keep up with her books until someone on an email list mentioned her. Now I'm scrambling to catch up.
|
Newest Reviews
see all reviews-
“I'd loved two of Hope Tarr's earlier historicals--My Lord Jack and Tempting, but forgot to keep up with her books until someone on an email list mentioned her. Now I'm scrambling to catch up.
DKayeS wrote this review Tuesday, November 18 2008. ( reply | permalink ) Was this review helpful? Yes | No
American history professor Maggie Holiday is putting her life back together after losing her parents and her sister in a plane crash. Part of that is a new house (well, an 1850s Victorian) in a new town, and a new job as assistant professor at the University of Mary Washington in Fredericksburg, Virginia. Except that her lover, D.C. psychiatrist Richard, calls it running away, and Maggie's starting to notice that he takes every opportunity to belittle her choices, and she realizes she needs to break things off with him.
There's no rush, though--he lives in the city, and hates the small town, and her old house, so he's out of her hair most of the time. First things first--exploring her house.
She finds a diary of a previous inhabitant, Isabel, who describes her romance with a Union officer, and Maggie begins having vivid dreams about the war and Isabel's life.
She gets a little more than she bargained for in the attic: an intruder, dressed in a civil war uniform--though how he got in, she doesn't know. He doesn't seem violent, and the way he talks and the fact that he calls her "Isabel" leads her to believe he's a relatively harmless reenactor who's a wee bit too caught up in his role. And then he seduces her.
Actually, he's Captain Ethan O'Malley, the same man Isabel had written about in the diary, and he was hanged when a man who wanted Isabel framed him for espionage. Now his ghost is trying to be reunited with Isabel, or rather, Isabel's reincarnation in Maggie, and to clear his name.
The Haunting is a short book, 244 pages, but it's complete nonetheless. Maggie's reactions are much more realistic than I've come to expect in this sort of paranormal romance--she keeps trying to figure out how the "intruder" got in, gets a new security system, etc. Even after the seduction, she doesn't immediately trust him, and it takes a lot of convincing before she believes, and remembers.
In addition, her relationship with Richard is, sadly, all too realistic. He tries to control her by belittling her and trying to make her doubt her sanity. But when she's doing what he wants, he acts loving and charming, so it's a real effort for her to break up with him--especially when she's not sure he's not right about her sanity... after all, she's having an affair with a ghost.
Even as I enjoyed the story, I had no idea how they'd resolve the issue in the end. We learn early on that Ethan has a limited amount of energy he can use to become corporeal, so their physical relationship can't continue in the same way indefinitely. I won't give away the solution, but it was clever and satisfying.
This was an "Extreme Blaze," but obviously, I read too much erotica, because I didn't even realize it until I read an Amazon review complaining that the sex scenes were too extreme. Obviously, a case of YMMV.
I'll definitely continue to look for more of Hope's backlist.”
“This book was probably the only Blaze that had me in tears. It also had some interesting sex scenes. ”
moonsong wrote this review Thursday, September 27 2007. ( reply | permalink ) Was this review helpful? Yes | No
“Courtesy of CK2S Kwips and Kritiques
shewolf0316 wrote this review Wednesday, July 18 2007. ( reply | permalink ) Was this review helpful? Yes | No
Maggie Holliday has recently purchased an historic Virginia manor when her life is turned upside down on its axis. A strange sound one night led her to the attic, where she bumped into a dream man come to life. Oddly enough, this man, Ethan, is dressed in a Civil War era uniform and keeps calling her Isabel.
As it turns out, the sinfully seductive Ethan is the ghost of a soldier put to death over the love of a woman… Isabel. He has been waiting for Isabel to return to him and is convinced Maggie is her reincarnation. Just as Maggie is coming around to believing him, an enemy from their past life has shown up in a reincarnation as well, and he will do anything to keep Maggie for himself.
I have to preface the rest of this review by saying this was my first book I’ve ever read in the Blaze line from Harlequin and the jury is still out on whether or not I’ll be reading any more. I’ve been assured by multiple people that the things about this story that totally put me off are not typical of this category line but even so it will be a long time before I decide to try another one, when and if I decide to give it another shot.
I absolutely love the premise of the story in The Haunting. After all who can resist a sexy soldier ghost searching for his long lost love who just happened to be reincarnated in to a modern day academic? Not me that’s for sure! I was even willing to set aside my initial misgivings about the fact it was not just a Blaze, but an Extreme Blaze to give it a try. The story was beautifully written and I love Hope Tarr’s style and think she did a wonderful job bringing Ethan and Maggie to life. I especially loved the concept that every soul on earth has a specific task they are expected to complete in this lifetime and that is what guides their life. This idea is woven throughout the entire story and gives the love story an added depth. There is a fantastic twist at the end I never saw coming as it was an idea I never even though of.
Ethan and Maggie/Isabel are wonderfully developed and grow so much by the end of the story. Their insecurities and Maggie’s disbelief over what Ethan tells her are very real. If such a thing could happen in real life and happened to me, I’d probably react almost exactly like Maggie, though I’d have probably been in near hysteria over a ghost showing up in my attic and telling me I’m his dead lover. The villain is portrayed well also, even if his sexual inclinations were a bit too sick and twisted for me to be comfortable during the scenes presented in his point of view.
Now for what I didn’t like about the story… Granted I am admittedly not exactly an erotica fan though I do read and enjoy it now and again when a particular author or storyline catches my attention. The Haunting appealed to me enough on both of these counts which is why I tried it. Unfortunately, this sexual content in this story was way too much for me. The language doesn’t bother me as it gives the book a grittier, earthier feeling. The sex scenes though blew my mind and almost made me quit listening more than once. I am very grateful I was not listening to this one in the car though or I’d have been positively mortified should one of the explicit scenes happened while my windows were open! It was primarily the details in the villain’s perspective that got to me. He is one sick sex fiend and the details of what he did or wanted to do were something I most certainly could have done without.
I guess a simple way of putting it is that I absolutely loved The Haunting, except for the strong sexual content that makes up so much of the book. However, readers who enjoy “naughtier” books with a strong plot and well developed characters will positively adore this book.
© Kelley A. Hartsell, April 2007. All rights reserved.”
displaying 1-3 of 3
