Now, don't get me wrong, Decipher have never been a patch on Wizards of the Coast, but I've been very pleased with most of their Lord of the Rings Roleplaying Game books. It's mostly very high quality and very well presented. So what happened with the Hero's Journal? It's about 30 pages, very thin paperback... basically, it's nothing more than a notepad, and worthy about $2.99. Maybe if they provided three in the pack for more players I'd be happy (but still not with the quality).