Books
 

Members with This Book

  • Katie G
  • k. s
  • Katie L
  • VIS Tweenagers
  • Shelley H
  • Kate B
  • Bob P
  • Bethany
  • Benjamin W
  • Rik W
  • Kim M
  • Patricia M
  • Noddle
  • Morarwen
  • Nat
  • Smiles *
See all 36 members with this book on their shelves »

Most Helpful Reviews

see all reviews

Liked It

Rik W
  • Rated 4 stars

This has become probably one of my favorite seriously. Just ingeniously well written young adult science fiction. The producers of the most recent movie adaptation should be shot in the head.

I just adore Susan Cooper's writing. Even though I think L'Engle's premise and mythos are way...

see full review » see other reviews »
 

Newest Reviews

see all reviews
  • Rik W
      • Rated 4 stars

    This has become probably one of my favorite seriously. Just ingeniously well written young adult science fiction. The producers of the most recent movie adaptation should be shot in the head.

    I just adore Susan Cooper's writing. Even though I think L'Engle's premise and mythos are way more original and creative, Cooper's technical writing skills are just exemplary.

    I found the whole Arthurian thing kind of disappointing as it's really not essential to the stories and I think actually taints their originality. If the Cooper had gone the extra mile to wrap all that up in her own original mythology, these stories would have been impeccable.

    That criticism aside, these are still some of the most enjoyable fantasy books I have read. Seriously. The best.

    Rik W wrote this review Friday, November 20 2009. ( reply | permalink ) Was this review helpful? Yes | No
    Post Cancel
    Kate B
      • Rated 5 stars

    I never tire of reading this series. It was the beginning of my love affair with Arthurian legend, compelled me to try and teach myself Welsh, and lead to many dreams of being an Old One.

    Kate B wrote this review Wednesday, January 28 2009. ( reply | permalink ) Was this review helpful? Yes | No
    Post Cancel
Advertisement