Reviewed by
an Amazon user,
2000-09-04
If you've never read the chronicles, choose any one of the original 7 and then make an INFORMED choice on whether to buy this book.
I first discovered this picture-book while looking for Books 5 & 6 at the library to continue our family read-aloud of the Chronicles. At first blush, I was delighted someone had made pre-school versions of these books, so we could now share Narnia with my young niece, give her something more satisfying than those vapid Disney heroines. However, upon closer inspection, I was disappointed. The lovely illustrations just don't seem true to the spirit of the line drawings in the original books, nor even to the original text's descriptions.
Modernizing and over-glamourizing (to say nothing of parsing) this series robs our kids of the rich experience the chronicles are AS IS, either read alone or aloud. C.S. Lewis' wonderful command of the English language alone is enough reason to give your kids only the 'real' thing. Yes, the originals ARE deep books, but they give even very young children much fodder for their imaginations and provide excellent models of 'noble' behavior in 'average'(fallible and redeemable) children.
A chapter takes an adult about 15 minutes to read aloud. Add another 5 minutes for Q & A or other interaction/discussion with your young listener, and -- ta-da -- you've met your 20-minutes-a-day reading requirement. If you feel your child is too young now (for whatever reason) to enjoy the originals, then simply WAIT until you think he or she IS old enough. Age has its privilege, and waiting its rewards.