I am very surprised that "Sing You Home" is getting such poor reviews. I am a huge Picoult fan and so far (I'm on page 283) this is one, if not my absolute favorite of hers. I think the plot is riveting, the romance is true and moving, and I feel very emotionally attached to the characters. Why do you think there is such a disconnect between myself and other Picoult fans? Could it simply be that others are having a hard time rooting for a homosexual character?