Members with This Book
Most Helpful Reviews
see all reviews
Liked It “Not many have a voice like Tim O'Brien.” see full review » see other reviews » |
Newest Reviews
see all reviews-
“Pretty good read. Deals with middle age and dreams undiscovered.”
Emjaycee wrote this review Friday, September 30, 2011. ( reply | permalink ) Was this review helpful? Yes | No
“Quick simple read about a college reunion and where life took the characters”
Hillary H wrote this review Friday, February 25, 2011. ( reply | permalink ) Was this review helpful? Yes | No“Not many have a voice like Tim O'Brien.”
Jill Brustad wrote this review Tuesday, February 8, 2011. ( reply | permalink ) Was this review helpful? Yes | No
“I thoroughly enjoyed it but love everything O'Brien writes.”
Kate W wrote this review Thursday, January 13, 2011. ( reply | permalink ) Was this review helpful? Yes | No
“a good read”
Caitlin M wrote this review Wednesday, August 11, 2010. ( reply | permalink ) Was this review helpful? Yes | No
“Again, this is a book that shows that its not always the subject of a novel that makes it enjoyable. This story is based on the reunion of a bunch of college classmates and their backstories. As someone who wasn't even born when the events of the story were happening, I still found myself engaged in the story because of the writing. There is something in here for everyone...romance, heartbreak (mostly heartbreak), war, family drama...its a great mix of characters and relationships. ”
Ms. Short wrote this review Friday, February 12, 2010. ( reply | permalink ) Was this review helpful? Yes | No
“Though a compelling read, I usually like books with a bit more going on. The fact that this wasn't one of those means, I suspect, I must like Tim O'Brien's writing style. The characters were real and engaging. I would certainly try reading other stuff he has written.”
kimode wrote this review Saturday, January 2, 2010. ( reply | permalink ) Was this review helpful? Yes | No
“Critics didn't like this book, but I think it's vastly underrated. There are about 10 pages in here that I think are O'Brien's best writing. Book is not as consistent as The Things They Carried, but it has some great moments.”
Edward B wrote this review Wednesday, December 16, 2009. ( reply | permalink ) Was this review helpful? Yes | No“Funny and sad at the same time. Great characterizations.”
Les G wrote this review Friday, September 25, 2009. ( reply | permalink ) Was this review helpful? Yes | No
“This review is from my blog:
Sagecoveredhills wrote this review Sunday, April 6, 2008. ( reply | permalink ) Was this review helpful? Yes | No
Do you have a burning desire to attend class reunions? If yes, read this book! Do you still believe that those in the 60s had it all together? If yes, read this book! It’s July 2001 and the 1969 graduation class of Darton Hall College have come together for their 30th reunion. Do the math. Yeah, it’s been 31 years since they graduated. Someone screwed up. Actually, they’re all screwed up. During the two days of the reunion, in which way too much alcohol is consumed, we learn all about their past and what brought them to the present. Surprisingly, most all of them are financially well off. They’d be considered a success in the world’s eyes, despite their divorces and heartbreaks and screwed up lives. The reunion consists of receptions, banquets, dances and even a chapel service for those members of their class who lived “abridged lives.” (love that term).
The book primarily focuses on a group of students who once hung out but had lost contact over the years. There’s David, the guy who in July 1969 led a platoon in Vietnam. His unit is wiped out and he’s shot in both feet. He survives but loses a leg. When he gets back, Marla, his college girlfriend marries him. But he can’t get the war out of his head. They divorce, but meet back up at the reunion.
Then there’s Billy. He fled to Canada to avoid the war. Dorothy, his college girlfriend, was supposed to come with him, but she chickened out. She was a Catholic Nixon chic, who just couldn't do it. She goes on to marry a rich guy. The Canadian guy marries, but his wife is killed (sounds like she may have committed suicide by stepping in front of a bus). It was a sad marriage; she found she couldn’t compete with his love for his former girlfriend.
Then there’s Paulette, a Presbyterian minister who is screwed up and got booted from her pulpit because of an inappropriate affair (and it didn’t involve sex). O’Brien, in his discussing Paulette’s failures, shows that he doesn’t understand Presbyterian Church government, but that's okay. Paulette makes an interesting character in the book and she is one of the few who leaves the reunion healthier than when she came. She’s a fitness nut and has the best body of the women present. Paulette’s friend, Ellie, tells about her affair with Harmon, one of their classmates who had an "abridged life." Ellie and Harmon met at a lake in Northern Minnesota. He has heart problems; he goes swimming and dies. She decides to tell her husband at the reunion which results in his early departure.
Spooky is still a crazy and attractive 30 years later. She’s married to two men (by their consent) at the same time. Yet, there’s this old thing for Marv. The two of them have always flirted, but had never become a pair. Marv is a successful broom tycoon with a size 52 waist and is married to a woman who has blackmailed him (after he lied to her). You’ll have to read the book to find out what happens to Marv and Spooky. There are a few other characters like the state Lt. Governor, who had spurred the love of his life because she wanted to be a Lutheran missionary. She became a missionary and he went into politics and they’re both receiving distinguished alumni awards.
This is my fourth O’Brien book. Reading it I was reminded why I didn't like reunions even though my class ain't nearly as screwed up as this one. O'Brien is an engaging writing and creates convincing characters, yet this book is the least favorite of the ones I’ve read of him. If you haven’t read O’Brien’s Vietnam short stories, The Things They Carried, I highly recommend it.
”
