Books

graceroxas
  • Rated 5 stars

80-85 percent into this book, I began to feel that no one can stand writing it and then living with an ending --- that the book is crashing towards with an inevitable logic by then --- without holding a certain compromised view of life in general.

So I did a little spadework on the author, Walter M. Miller, and little wonder, he did a euthanasia on himself after years of spiritual coma.

It invites comparison with another classic that problematized the war-mongering during and in the immediate aftermath of WWII, the vastly more popular Catch-22. There's that same satirical tone, though of vastly different magnitudes, the same character-driven undertones of despair, and foregone assumptions about demi-gods with clay feet and putty brains running the world's affairs.

But I find "Canticle..." richer in imagination, plot-wise. In talking about a new Dark Age of Man, one's tendency is to ask 'why not' rather than brace for a suspension of belief, even if the notion seems so farfetched now in this technology-driven age.

graceroxas wrote this review Monday, December 10, 2007. ( reply | view 4 replies | permalink )
  • Michael C

    michael c said:

    Nice explication, graceroxas. I've enjoyed thid book for several years and pull out something new each time. Thank you for your insights.
    M

    posted Tuesday, December 11, 2007 ( | view 4 replies )
  • graceroxas

    graceroxas said:

    Hi, Rachel's "birth" does seem to be a mitigation of a dreary view of history that Miller depicted in the book. Also an invitation to a sequel, although that never really happened of course.

    posted Tuesday, December 11, 2007 ( | view 4 replies )
  • Michael C

    michael c said:

    Wasn't there an "unfinished" manuscript that was published after his death?

    M

    posted Tuesday, December 11, 2007 ( | view 4 replies )
  • Katydid

    katydid said:

    Look for "St Leibowitz and the Wild Horse Woman". It doesn't look nearly as amazing as the original (based on the short description), but sequels rarely are...

    posted Thursday, December 27, 2007 ( | view 4 replies )