“And this is the first book
I have read little or no children's fiction. But the fabulous art work on the cover of this book caught my eye. The catchline "And he is the good guy" had me hooked. It looked like an interesting read - a young girl paired with a detective, thrown into harm's way and a magical adventure in Ireland.
The plot develops well throughout. Plenty of twists, betrayals, deductions and action. At the very initial outset (first few chapters), Stepahnie is threatened with death when she tries to pass a solitary night at dead uncle Gordon's home which she inherited. The mysterious stranger in a hat and suit reappears to rescue her. Then on magical elements unfold along with real ones.
For a children's detective novel, it is well written and not too complicated. I have never truly read Harry Potter but from what I see this is better writing and fictional work than the Rowling mania. The magic does not overwhelm the plot and events. Its there but plenty of legwork also needs to be done.
The characters are interesting and generate a lot of curiosity into this hidden world. The concept of 3 names, the Scepter of the Ancients, the elements (elemental magic), magical twin in the mirror, Mages and professions of the characters; all are quite refreshing and appealing for a first time reader of this type of fiction.
It can easily become a crossover book that can be read by both children and adults. Stephanie's resolute and brave front, Skullduggery's quips, persona of Tanith, China, Ghastly, vile Nefarian, his Hollow Men are all very well created.
By the last few chapters things fall into place and clues you left behind in earlier chapters come together to create a memorable story. Concise and descriptive the language is easy and attractive. A very good first novel by Derek Landy.”
udey wrote this review Sunday, September 16 2007.
(
reply |
permalink )
