“I have waited to write this review until now as I was too unfamiliar with the life and character of Mary and Abraham's son, Robert, and I wanted to have a better understanding of him before condemning "Mary" as overly critical of the boy Lincoln. This book may provide some insight into how Mary Lincoln saw the world, but I believe that it portrays Robert T. Lincoln in an entirely false light. I understand that this book is a novel, and as such the author may take any liberties she wants in showing her characters interactions. But, when you're using real people, historical people, and ones that are beloved by an entire nation, you have a responsibility to depict them in the way they truly were. "Mary" depicts Robert T. Lincoln to be a boy and man who is wholly incapable of affection. He is cold, callous, and void of emotion for the feelings of those that love him most, including his wife, brothers, and mother. He also appears to be entirely indifferent toward his father.
In reading non-fiction titles on the subject of Robert T. Lincoln, I have found the opposite to be true. Although he shunned the fame and accolades brought on by being the son of the 16th President, he led a very successful life, exhibiting all of the character and honor that also defined his father. He was a doting husband and father, who cared deeply for his family.
I understand that the real Mary Lincoln resented Robert for being the driving force behind her institutionalization in 1875, however, it is clear to me that he only did so when he felt there was no other alternative. Many people of his day believed he did so to get at her portion of the estate, but, upon being released from the hospital Mary found that all of her money was still there, and then some.
I find this novel to be insulting to the memory of the entire Lincoln family.”
Eric S wrote this review Monday, January 30, 2012.
(
reply |
permalink )
