The Wars
 

The Wars

by Timothy Findley

Robert Ross is a Canadian officer caught up in the nightmare world of World War I trench warfare; a world of mud and smoke, chlorine gas and rotting corpses. In this world gone mad, he performs a last desperate act to declare his commitment to life in the midst of death. (read review)

Top tags: fictionhistorical fictionfindleycanadacanadian literature (all tags)

Overview: Amazon Reviews

An Accomplishment
  • Rated 5 stars
Reviewed by an Amazon user, 2008-07-12
I came across this book when I had to use another of Findley's work and do some comparison with the awesome "Not Wanted on the Voyage" for my final paper in college. Since then, I've been a fan of Findley. This book is quite easy to read, and for those unfamiliar with his works, shudder not, because Findley writes most delightfully. This is an easy read. I would keep myself from writing too much because there are lots of small surprises in store--my favorite part is probably the gas attack scene.
Characterization is strong; and the flow of the story is well-paced. Findley succeeded in creating a memorable tragic hero in Robert Ross.
When you are done with this, try "Pilgrim: A Novel."
Please read this review before buying 'The Wars'.
  • Rated 5 stars
Reviewed by an Amazon user, 2007-06-06
I am surprised at the reviews of this novel. I see some people claiming to have literally burned this book and I see a `teacher' who condemns a Governor General's Award winning novel without the courtesy of proper punctuation or even capital letters (on Amazon.ca). And I see people claiming that this novel is the greatest ever produced by a Canadian. The truth is somewhere in between. But make no mistake: it is a classic for good reason.

Anger comes from confusion so it is no surprise to see many angry people reacting to `The Wars'. It is a difficult read. Robert Ross is a difficult character to identify with because Findley holds him at arm's length for almost the entire novel. The only instances I remember where the reader is given direct access to Robert's innermost thoughts are in the opening section, before he enlists in the army. From there we are shown his actions and only the most obvious of thoughts. Much of the novel is presented as hearsay, where the reader sees the toll the war takes on both his family and personal life, and this is perhaps the reason for the negative reviews here: the reader cannot become attached to Robert Ross. Findley does not present empathy as an option. We are forced to examine his actions coolly with little emotion involved save the horror of killing or the pleasure of love. What does this say about Findley's goal with this novel? Why does he not allow us to be close to Robert Ross? Because he is not a hero. He is not a great man. He was the average soldier (or officer, in this case) and his trials were average for the Great War.

This is a novel about World War One written sixty years (or so) after the armistice, and we are now approaching its one hundred year anniversary. So why do readers think it should be a rip roaring adventure of bravery and heroism? Wake up people. It is a novel about the legacy the war has left. It is about how we were and are affected by it and that is why it is written from the point of view or a reseacher/historian. It is about darkness and savagery and how these things are in all of us, only to be revealed by the horrors we subject each other to. Look at the things Robert has to deal with within his own army. Are the Germans the `bad guys' in this novel? We only ever see one, and he shows great humanity and sacrifice. Robert's own army wreaks as much destruction and havoc in the lives of their own soldiers as they do to the Germans. It is not a heroic tale of Us versus Them. It is a cautionary tale of Us vs. Ourselves.

Do not expect `Saving Private Ryan'. Expect `Apocalypse Now'. Do not expect a page turner. Expect a meditation on humanity's darkest hour, and you will not be disappointed. This is a novel to be read by the intelligent and the brave, not the simple and arrogant. Approach it with the right mindset and you will find a classic.
One of the best
  • Rated 5 stars
Reviewed by an Amazon user, 2006-04-24
One of the best what? One of the best Canadian novels, one of the best war novels . . . take your pick.

Joeseph Jonston must only like stories where there are only good people doing nice things, and where children are sheltered from the scary fact that sometimes the world is a bad place. I think this is the problem when you have a work of art as powerful and brilliant as The Wars --- it gets assigned in high schools, and people who wouldn't know a good book from a hole in the ground are made to read it.

The Wars examines the physical, emotional, psychological, and spiritual wages of World War One (I think the plural in the title references the fact that there are so many other "little" wars simultaneously going on within the main character, within his family, within society, etc).

Findley explores his themes with powerful, poetic, and concise prose. The Wars is a short book, and Findley's fluid style means it can be read quickly. However, not a single word is wasted. The prose is rich with fresh imagery, but those images are never just decoration, or descriptive showmanshp --- they all have their purpose and their place. This is one of the calling cards of a great writer.

Some would say the age warning is appropriate. Some of the events of the plot and some of the images are indeed explicitly violent or sexual. They are never gratuitous, and are used to drive home the horror of World War One, but the more squeemish or puritanical readers may find them off-putting.
Total Garbage! and not for kids
  • Rated 1 stars
Reviewed by an Amazon user, 2006-02-17
This book was a total waste of my time. The plot was bad, and there was something bad about almost every character. What was this guy thinking. If there were negative stars, this book would be -5. And seeing that kids were reading this, I'm getting a Nauseous feeling. Too many issues. And what Idiot would rank this book at even 2 stars never mind 5. This piece of $h!t isn't worth anyones time.
the characters and relationship of mr. and mrs. ross
  • Rated 5 stars
Reviewed by an Amazon user, 2005-03-29
characters relationship, describe the relationship of mr. and mrs ross, is there any details of their courship, what is the insight into their relationship?
© 2008 Shelfari, Inc. | Portions of Shelfari.com are Copyright © 1996-2008 Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates. Terms & Conditions | Privacy Policy | Copyright Policy