Books

  • Erastes

    erastes said:

    I feel sorry for JKR too. I know she doesn't need my approval, but I'd rather be comparing her to Pullman than Brown,. Shame that I can't.

    Hermione appears to have learned "How the Dark Arts work" according to JKR - I can't imagine when that happened, seeing as it was her worst subject.

    I can't see any of those "values" that you imbue Harry with, I'm afraid, except depression and whining.

    Bah. I don't need to justify my opinion. If you want to see how I felt about HBP or DH then go and read the Sporking communities on Livejournal. I'm happy to look straight at the Emperor and say how few clothes he's wearing.

    posted Saturday, July 28 2007 ( | view 2 replies )
  • evol-ache-pee

    evol-ache-pee said:

    So when harry is walking to his death, you don't see courage ? It's just stupidity maybe ? Pffft, ya right, pretty sure if you wanted to save the world it would take a great deal of courage to convince yourself that you must die and to actually go along with it.

    I'm not sure why you say that Hermione's worst subject was DADA, cause even then, she managed to get an Outstanding on her O.W.L.S.

    I know you have the right to your opinion, but I am too. And my opinion is that you're wrong.

    I also agree that in the epilogue, it had to be vague, the whole "looking through mist" makes absolute sense.

    posted Sunday, July 5 2009
  • evol-ache-pee

    evol-ache-pee said:

    So when harry is walking to his death, you don't see courage ? It's just stupidity maybe ? Pffft, ya right, pretty sure if you wanted to save the world it would take a great deal of courage to convince yourself that you must die and to actually go along with it.

    I'm not sure why you say that Hermione's worst subject was DADA, cause even then, she managed to get an Outstanding on her O.W.L.S.

    I know you have the right to your opinion, but I am too. And my opinion is that you're wrong.

    I also agree that in the epilogue, it had to be vague, the whole "looking through mist" makes absolute sense.

    posted Sunday, July 5 2009
Advertisement