Books

Reviews

  • Sort by:
 
  • The Didymus Contingency
    • Rated 1 stars

    Spoiler alert - don't read this until you've read the book :-)
    The most glaring thing about this book is it's ignorance of history. The characters think, "I want to see Jesus, so I'll just go back to 28 AD, 28 years after the exact date of this birth." It doesn't work that way. The Christian calendar was instated hundreds of years after Jesus' birth, and is at best an estimate.
    The author follows the Bible like it's a script, with everything happening in the exact order and everyone saying and doing everything exactly like the modern Bible says. Even the Gospels don't agree on some things, and they were written at least 30 years AFTER Jesus' death. The New Testament is not a historical document, it is a religious document, and should not be taken as historical fact. Following the Bible this closely took all the fun out of the book. Everyone knows how it's going to end.
    When it became obvious that the author was going to piggy-back on the Bible to the letter, and when the character named "Tom" (who happens to be a bit of a "doubter") was chosen as a disciple, the ending of the book became wrapped in a nice little bow on about page 50. There is no reason to read on from there because the reader already knows how it's going to play out.
    When the characters go back in time the third person they meet is THE Jesus! First, the name Jesus was a popular Jewish name in that era, so of course someone named Jesus will be on every street corner. If you say, "I'm looking for Jesus," you'd find plenty of them, but not THE Jesus. Second, since the dates in the Bible aren't clear, it would be impossible to find anyone without a lot of investigation.

    There are a few prejudices in this book that I found offensive:
    -all "hicks" are violent idiots
    -all business executives are at best jerks and at worst evil
    -all non-believers are wrong and know absolutely nothing about Christianity
    -all military people are violent killers

    Making all of the "bad guys" possessed by demons was a strange thing for the author to do. The "devil made me do it" attitude takes the responsibility of doing bad things away from the characters. When you do bad things are you possessed by the devil? No, you just made a bad decision. In this book's case it took all remaining unpredictability out of the plot.
    There is a point where the characters say the world would be terrible without Christianity. The U.S., the greatest nation ever in the history of the universe wouldn't exist! Come on!! First, we are not a Christian nation. We have freedom of and from religion. Second, if Christianity hadn't existed something else would have taken it's place. The world could have been better without Christianity or it could have been worse.
    There is a decent underlying story in this book, it's just under too many layers of Christian propaganda to shine. It's hidden under a bushel!

    bkl001 wrote this review Sunday, February 14, 2010. ( reply | view 1 replies | permalink )
  • Ahead of the Curve: Two Years at Harvard Business School
    • Rated 4 stars

    I have an MBA from a slightly less august school (Iowa State University), and I thought that this was a very interesting read. We used Harvard business cases in our materials and talked about Harvard every now and then, so it was interesting to see what the hype is about.
    Really most of it does seem to be just that: hype. Sure, our professors were not world famous and we didn't have major league CEOs flying in from all over to speak to us, but I found Broughton's description of the MBA experience to be very close to mine, and probably very close to almost every MBA student's.
    This book is also interesting because it's written from the perspective of a non-American, non-business major (undergrad) earning his MBA in the US.
    I would recommend this book for anyone curious about Harvard business school, considering earning their MBA, or, like me, wanting to see why Harvard gets all the attention.

    bkl001 wrote this review Monday, February 2, 2009. ( reply | permalink )
  • Glasshouse
    • Rated 5 stars

    Stross does an excellent job looking at present day society from a 3rd person perspective. It makes for a great commentary on who we are, why some people do the things they do, and makes for some good humor (like when the women are trying to figure out what a "husband" is).
    After a while I started to wonder where the science fiction was. Usually people are using futuristic gadgets and futuristic things all the time in a science fiction book. It was in the beginning, then only in the main character's dreams and memories for most of the rest of the book.

    bkl001 wrote this review Friday, January 25, 2008. ( reply | permalink )
  • Millenium

    by Ben Bova
    • Rated 3 stars

    I think the most interesting part about this book is its 1976 perspective of how things would be in 1999.
    -One of the major characters is - hold on to your hats! - black! And I think it was meant to surprise 1976 readers that a black man would be a colonel and be an important person.
    -When someone suggests that a woman character be left in charge of the moon base, they look at each other like, "Are you sure this thing won't explode with a woman running the place?" Maybe that would have shocked people in 1976.
    -Going on a trip to the space station? Be sure to bring your cigarettes! The author has people smoking in the space station, on the moon, everywhere. Do you really think they would have adjusted air filtration systems to accommodate smokers?
    -A group of VIPs get rooms with color TVs. Color TVs! I would think that even in 1976 someone could see that there would be no such thing as black and white TVs in 20 years' time, but the author makes sure to mention the color TVs. Maybe black and white TVs were so widespread in 1976 that it was important to specify to the readers how high-tech people were going to be.

    bkl001 wrote this review Monday, December 17, 2007. ( reply | permalink )
  • Cryptonomicon
    • Rated 2 stars

    The historical and encryption parts were interesting, but I find this book to be a bit tedious. A full page devoted to describing a guy eating Captain Crunch? How does that fit into the story? I agree with the other comments about the editing: chop the length in half and it would improve the book a lot.

    bkl001 wrote this review Saturday, October 20, 2007. ( reply | permalink )