“In this third book of Victorian suspense featuring Lady Julia Grey (and you should read the first two before this one, even though the story here can stand on its own), Julia finds herself in a very Gothic, Romantic, Mysterious, Bronte-esque tale set in a lonely half-ruined mansion on the Yorkshire Moors. Julia's sister Portia had agreed to help the enigmatic detective, Nicholas Brisbane, sort out his newly acquired mansion, Grimsgrave, and Julia, drawing on her newfound determination to truly live life, insists on going with her to determine where she stands with Brisbane once and for all.
Of course, the old mansion is chock full of mystery, secrets and all sorts of nastiness that is very slowly unraveled. There are the remnants of a proud and ancient family who were the former owners of the place, a profligate son who was an avid Egyptologist with a scandal in his past and a collection of artifacts, there are surly villagers, tales of a drowned village with a bell that rings to herald the imminent death of one of the members of the old family, there are gypsies with healing draughts and ties to Brisbane's past... And there is the mystery of Brisbane, himself. What is he doing at the run-down mansion? Why is he avoiding Julia, or pushing her away--while at the same time engaging in the occasional fervent embrace and kiss?
The mystery plot is complex and detailed and slow to develop, but suits the brooding atmosphere. It does build to an exciting climax and then the denouement continues to be revealed bit by bit, again, as the book draws to an end. The romantic plot is also slow to build, pacing along with the mystery, and intertwined with it, particularly as it intersects with Brisbane's past.
The tone and subjects of each of the Lady Julia Grey books have varied greatly, the first being more typical Victorian Mystery/Suspense, the second a cozy murder mystery set in an English Mansion. This exploration into the territory of _Wuthering Heights_ and _Jane Eyre_ seemed to work well considering Brisbane's gypsy background and Rochester and Heathcliff-like personality. I have enjoyed seeing Julia's confidence grow during the first two books. Unfortunately there were a few times in this book where she behaves like a typical flighty romance heroine, saying she'll stay forever one moment and ready to pack her bags and flee the next. And sometimes her intelligence seems questionable, but thankfully, at the end she's back to her confident and well-reasoned self. The mystery was better as an atmospheric backdrop than an actual puzzle since it seemed a little obvious to me towards the end. But thankfully, the romantic elements finally emerge at the end to create a fine conclusion.”
aprillee wrote this review Wednesday, May 20 2009.
(
reply |
permalink )