“I liked the first half of this book better than the last half. It is an original and fascinating world, and the protagonist is strong and interesting, but ultimately both the protagonist and the world felt under explored. The only other characters given any real attention are gods of some sort or another, but as the narrator often reminds us, they cannot really be understood by mortals. The other human characters are two dimensional or worse, just part of a faceless crowd (that the narrator nonetheless is confident despising and dismissing). I didn't mean this review to be so harsh, I did enjoy the book, and the character Sieh will probably stay with me for a long time. But like in the Hunger Games, with which this book has much in common, it felt increasingly like social commentary, and a poorly thought out form of commentary, bereft of real insight, the closer to the conclusion it came.
In any case, I don't think I'll continue with this series, but I will be interested to follow the author's career - the book is engaging, entertaining, and has genuine moments of wonder.”
Jeff C wrote this review Saturday, December 31, 2011.
(
reply |
permalink )