1 of 1 members found this review helpful.
“I went to Albany High School in Albany, GA, from 1960 through 1963, my father stationed there with the Air Force, in the same time frame as this novel. I lived there four years. I went through integration in the school, my church and surreptitiously watched meetings of KKK in downtown. I was there for the Albany Movement when Dr. King marched and was jailed. I would not presume to know what any of these women went through, or how any of them acted. I can only reflect on the way that high school students talked about blacks. It was rude, nasty and scary. Nevertheless, there were other aspects of my life there that were very positive, one being I had two of the best teachers I have ever had, and I am grateful today for the love of language and Shakespeare that Billy Bragg and Mrs. Dobbins instilled in me.
From that time and experience I can opine that this novel portrays a very authentic picture of the South at this time. I am, however, disappointed in several of the intense issues that were only addressed in a minor way. First I am very aware of the sexual abuse that so many of the maids in white families experienced and that was only touched on in a very minor way. The strong violence that took place in and around Jackson is only, again, briefly described with the killing of Medger Evers, who lived so close to these women. And, the portrayal of the men both black and white in the book was skimmed over, presenting little of the white influence and involvement, and with the black men only as violent and not accountable. While I understand that the book is looking at the plight of the domestic help, these factors were strong in their lives as well.
I was also disappointed in Skeeter. She decides to write the book, in the face of danger and in tolerance if it leaks out. However, when she finally ostracized from her community, has lost her suitor, and is alone, she continues to let the nasty Hilly and her mother control her life. I was waiting for her to finally let the witch have it. To speak up to Hilly and her other friends. It was extremely frustrating that she needed the nudge of the "help" and the ridicule of Missus Stein to get her moving with her own life. She seemed to miss the meaning of the bravery and tenacity of the maid. The paradox was frustrating.
Overall, I enjoyed the book, but I think it would have been stronger with some added depth.”